As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

11 Best Countertop Ice Makers, Compared

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

For most kitchens the Silonn SLIM41T is the countertop ice maker to get. Its listing claims 44 lb of nugget ice a day, first ice in 5 minutes, a 3L tank, a 40 dB rating and app control. If you only need plain bullet ice, the red Crzoe is the cheapest of the 11 picks and the Silonn SLIM01B adds a 2L tank for a little more. Every machine here plugs into a regular outlet and runs from a tank. We sorted them by their Amazon listings, not by using them ourselves.

Our top pick: Silonn 44 lb Smart Nugget Ice Maker.

Helpful first: Form Factor in Ice Makers: What It Is and Is It Worth It?

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1 Silonn 44 lb Smart Nugget Ice Maker Best overall Most kitchens Check price of Silonn 44 lb Smart Nugget Ice Maker on Amazon
2 Crzoe 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker with Handle Best budget Tight budgets Check price of Crzoe 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker with Handle on Amazon
3 Silonn Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lbs/Day Best bullet Daily drinks Check price of Silonn Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lbs/Day on Amazon
4 SenCre 60lb Nugget Ice Maker Best high output Entertainers Check price of SenCre 60lb Nugget Ice Maker on Amazon
5 Crzoe 35-lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker Best value nugget Nugget beginners Check price of Crzoe 35-lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker on Amazon
6 Frigidaire Compact 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker Best low-power RVs Check price of Frigidaire Compact 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker on Amazon
7 Antarctic Star 26 lb Compact Countertop Ice Maker Best for camping Camping Check price of Antarctic Star 26 lb Compact Countertop Ice Maker on Amazon
8 Igloo 26 Lb Portable Ice Maker with Handle Also great Picnics and BBQs Check price of Igloo 26 Lb Portable Ice Maker with Handle on Amazon
9 Comfee 26lbs Bullet Ice Maker Also great Narrow spots Check price of Comfee 26lbs Bullet Ice Maker on Amazon
10 Frigidaire 26 lb Portable Bullet Ice Maker Also great Busy counters Check price of Frigidaire 26 lb Portable Bullet Ice Maker on Amazon
11 SenCre 26.5lb Countertop Ice Maker Steel kitchens Check price of SenCre 26.5lb Countertop Ice Maker on Amazon

The best fit for you

Our 11 picks

Best overall

Silonn 44 lb Smart Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: Most kitchens

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
44 lbs/24h
Ice Type
Nugget
Batch Time
5 minutes
Water Supply
3L removable water tank
Daily Capacity
44 lbs/Day

View on Amazon: Silonn 44 lb Smart Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

On the counter, the Silonn SLIM41T nugget maker stands 15 inches tall and 10 inches wide, makes up to 44 lb a day from a removable 3L tank, and runs from the SmartBQ app, voice or touch.

Pros

  • 44 lb a day
  • 3L removable tank
  • 40 dB claim

Cons

  • Pricier than bullet makers
  • Tall for some cabinets

Good fit if

  • You want nugget ice daily
  • You want app scheduling

Skip if

  • You only fill coolers
  • Budget is under $100

Verdict: The best countertop all-rounder.

Best budget

Crzoe 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker with Handle

Best for: Tight budgets

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26 lbs
Storage Capacity
1.3 lbs
Ice Type
bullet
Batch Time
6-12 minutes
Daily Capacity
26 lbs/Day

View on Amazon: Crzoe 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker with Handle Affiliate link

The red Crzoe is a small bullet ice maker, about 10.4 inches tall, that makes 8 cubes per batch and 26 lb a day, with two cube sizes, a handle and a 5-second self-clean.

Pros

  • Cheapest pick
  • Handle
  • Fits under low cabinets

Cons

  • Batches can take up to 12 minutes
  • No tank size given

Good fit if

  • You want a second ice maker for the patio
  • You want the lowest outlay

Skip if

  • You need fast batches
  • You want nugget ice

Verdict: Best value on the counter.

Best bullet

Silonn Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lbs/Day

Best for: Daily drinks

Form Factor
Countertop (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26 lbs in 24 hours
Ice Type
Bullet
Batch Time
6 minutes
Water Supply
2L water tank
Features
Self-Cleaning

View on Amazon: Silonn Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lbs/Day Affiliate link

Silonn's SLIM01B is a black bullet maker with a 2L tank, 9 cubes every 6 minutes and up to 26 lb a day, plus a transparent lid and low-water and full-basket indicator lights.

Pros

  • 2L tank
  • 9 cubes per batch
  • Transparent lid

Cons

  • No handle
  • Quiet claim but no dB figure

Good fit if

  • You want bullet ice with few refills
  • You like simple controls

Skip if

  • You carry it around
  • You want a noise rating

Verdict: The best plain bullet maker here.

Best high output

SenCre 60lb Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: Entertainers

Form Factor
Countertop (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
60 lbs/24h
Storage Capacity
4.84 lbs
Ice Type
Nugget
Batch Time
5 minutes
Water Supply
Dual water tank (3L + 3.8L)

View on Amazon: SenCre 60lb Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

This grey SenCre nugget maker is the high-output countertop pick: 60 lb a day, dual tanks, a 4.84 lb basket, a sediment pre-filter, UV-C purification and a 40 dB claim.

Pros

  • 60 lb a day
  • 4.84 lb basket
  • UV-C and pre-filter

Cons

  • 16.7 inches wide
  • No model number

Good fit if

  • You entertain often
  • You want filtered ice

Skip if

  • Counter space is tight
  • You want app control

Verdict: The most ice from any countertop pick.

Best value nugget

Crzoe 35-lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: Nugget beginners

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
up to 35 lbs
Ice Type
nugget
Batch Time
6-7 minutes
Water Supply
1.1L water tank
Features
Self-Cleaning

View on Amazon: Crzoe 35-lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

The black Crzoe HZB-15NH/S is the value nugget pick on this list, making up to 35 lb of pebble ice a day from a 1.1L tank with a 15-minute auto-clean and a viewing window.

Pros

  • Nugget ice for less
  • 15-minute auto-clean
  • 8.27 inches wide

Cons

  • 1.1L tank
  • No noise figure

Good fit if

  • You want nugget ice without app extras
  • You have a narrow counter

Skip if

  • You want long runs between refills
  • You want smart features

Verdict: Nugget ice on a budget.

Best low-power

Frigidaire Compact 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker

Best for: RVs

Form Factor
Countertop (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26 lb per Day
Ice Type
ice cubes
Batch Time
5-6 minute
Daily Capacity
26 lbs/Day
Color
Black

View on Amazon: Frigidaire Compact 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker Affiliate link

The black Frigidaire EFIC128 makes 9 bullet cubes in 5 to 6 minutes and 26 lb a day, with a 105W rating, R600a refrigerant, a large transparent window and water-recycling meltwater.

Pros

  • 105W rated power
  • Frigidaire brand
  • Large viewing window

Cons

  • Low stock
  • No self-clean listed

Good fit if

  • You run on limited power
  • You want a big window

Skip if

  • You want automatic cleaning
  • You need it now

Verdict: A low-draw Frigidaire.

Best for camping

Antarctic Star 26 lb Compact Countertop Ice Maker

Best for: Camping

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26 lbs/day
Ice Type
bullet
Batch Time
6 min
Features
Self-Cleaning, Carry Handle
Application
Home, Bar, RV, Camping

View on Amazon: Antarctic Star 26 lb Compact Countertop Ice Maker Affiliate link

For camping, the Antarctic Star HZB-12Q is light at 11.8 lb with a handle, makes 8 bullet cubes in 6 minutes and 26 lb a day, and claims under 40 dB and 30% lower energy use.

Pros

  • 11.8 lb with handle
  • Under 40 dB
  • Self-cleaning

Cons

  • No tank size listed
  • Energy claim not benchmarked

Good fit if

  • You take it camping or tailgating
  • Quiet matters

Skip if

  • You want more than 26 lb
  • You want a big tank

Verdict: The travel-friendly pick.

Also great

Igloo 26 Lb Portable Ice Maker with Handle

Best for: Picnics and BBQs

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26 lbs
Storage Capacity
1.5 lbs
Ice Type
cylinder
Batch Time
7 minutes
Water Supply
1.5 qt water tank

View on Amazon: Igloo 26 Lb Portable Ice Maker with Handle Affiliate link

The black Igloo IGLICEBSC26BK makes 9 small or large cubes in about 7 minutes and 26 lb a day, with a 1.5-quart tank, a 120W motor, an LED panel and 1.5 lb of storage.

Pros

  • Igloo name
  • 1.5 lb storage
  • LED status panel

Cons

  • No clean cycle listed
  • 7-minute batches

Good fit if

  • You want a known cooler brand
  • You don't mind hand cleaning

Skip if

  • You want self-cleaning
  • You want faster batches

Verdict: A simple branded bullet maker.

Also great

Comfee 26lbs Bullet Ice Maker

Best for: Narrow spots

Form Factor
Countertop (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26 lbs/day
Ice Type
Bullet
Batch Time
6 minutes
Water Supply
1.3 L water tank
Features
Self-Cleaning

View on Amazon: Comfee 26lbs Bullet Ice Maker Affiliate link

Comfee's 26 lb CERI26B0ABB is a narrow 8.4-inch bullet maker making 8 bullets in 6 minutes from a 1.3L tank, with two sizes, one-touch self-cleaning and clear status lights.

Pros

  • 8.4 inches wide
  • One-touch self-clean
  • Low price

Cons

  • 1.3L tank
  • No handle

Good fit if

  • Space between appliances is tight
  • You want easy cleaning

Skip if

  • You want a big tank
  • You carry it often

Verdict: A slim, easy bullet maker.

Also great

Frigidaire 26 lb Portable Bullet Ice Maker

Best for: Busy counters

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
Up to 26 lbs.
Storage Capacity
1.5 lbs.
Ice Type
Bullet
Batch Time
7 minutes
Water Supply
2.1 qt. water tank

View on Amazon: Frigidaire 26 lb Portable Bullet Ice Maker Affiliate link

The black stainless Frigidaire EFIC120 is a 26 lb-a-day bullet maker with 9 cubes per 7 minutes, a 2.1-quart tank, a drain plug and a 1.5 lb basket.

Pros

  • 2.1-quart tank
  • Drain plug
  • Black stainless finish

Cons

  • 14.5 inches tall
  • No self-clean

Good fit if

  • You want a roughly 2L tank and a drain plug
  • You like Frigidaire styling

Skip if

  • Cabinets hang low
  • You want a clean cycle

Verdict: A big-tank Frigidaire for steady use.

SenCre 26.5lb Countertop Ice Maker

Best for: Steel kitchens

Form Factor
Countertop, Portable (what this guide is about)
Daily Ice Production
26.5 lbs
Storage Capacity
1.32 lbs
Ice Type
bullet
Batch Time
6 min
Water Supply
1.5L water tank

View on Amazon: SenCre 26.5lb Countertop Ice Maker Affiliate link

The SenCre ICM1258S is a stainless silver bullet maker with 9 cubes per 6 minutes, 26.5 lb a day, a 1.5L tank, a 1.32 lb basket and a CLEAN button; it weighs 17.8 lb.

Pros

  • Stainless silver look
  • CLEAN button
  • Fast 6-minute batches

Cons

  • Heavier than most
  • Higher price for a bullet maker

Good fit if

  • Looks matter on your counter
  • It will stay in one place

Skip if

  • You move it a lot
  • You want the best value

Verdict: Style over value.

Specifications side by side

Spec Silonn 44 lb Smart Nugget Ice Maker Crzoe 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker with Handle Silonn Bullet Ice Maker, 26 lbs/Day SenCre 60lb Nugget Ice Maker Crzoe 35-lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker Frigidaire Compact 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker Antarctic Star 26 lb Compact Countertop Ice Maker Igloo 26 Lb Portable Ice Maker with Handle Comfee 26lbs Bullet Ice Maker Frigidaire 26 lb Portable Bullet Ice Maker SenCre 26.5lb Countertop Ice Maker
Daily Ice Production 44 lbs/24h 26 lbs 26 lbs in 24 hours 60 lbs/24h up to 35 lbs 26 lb per Day 26 lbs/day 26 lbs 26 lbs/day Up to 26 lbs. 26.5 lbs
Storage Capacity not stated 1.3 lbs not stated 4.84 lbs not stated not stated not stated 1.5 lbs not stated 1.5 lbs. 1.32 lbs
Ice Type Nugget bullet Bullet Nugget nugget ice cubes bullet cylinder Bullet Bullet bullet
Form Factor Countertop countertop, portable Countertop Countertop countertop Countertop countertop countertop, portable Countertop Countertop countertop
Batch Time 5 minutes 6-12 minutes 6 minutes 5 minutes 6-7 minutes 5-6 minute 6 min 7 minutes 6 minutes 7 minutes 6 min
Water Supply 3L removable water tank not stated 2L water tank Dual water tank (3L + 3.8L) 1.1L water tank not stated not stated 1.5 qt water tank 1.3 L water tank 2.1 qt. water tank 1.5L water tank
Drain Type not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated Drain plug not stated
Daily Capacity 44 lbs/Day 26 lbs/Day not stated not stated not stated 26 lbs/Day 26 lbs/Day not stated not stated 26 lbs/Day not stated
Features Self-Cleaning Self-Cleaning Self-Cleaning Self-Cleaning Self-Cleaning not stated Self-Cleaning, Carry Handle not stated Self-Cleaning not stated Self-Cleaning
Application Home, Kitchen, Party Home, Kitchen, Party Home, Office, Bar, Kitchen, Party not stated Home, Office, Party not stated Home, Bar, RV, Camping not stated Home, Office, RV not stated Home, Office, Bar, Kitchen, RV
Color Silver Grey Red Upgrade-black Grey Black Black Black Black Black BLACK STAINLESS Stainless Steel Silver
Room not stated not stated Home Bar not stated not stated not stated Home Bar not stated not stated not stated Home Bar
Dimensions 12.1 × 10 × 15 inches 11 × 8.66 × 10.4 inches 12.3 × 8.7 × 12.5 inches 13.7 × 16.7 × 13.7 inches 11 × 8.27 × 12.2 inches 12 × 11 × 14.5 inches 10.4 × 8.66 × 11.2 inches 8.98 × 12.6 × 11.7 inches 11.6 × 8.4 × 11.6 inches 15 × 11 × 14.5 inches 8.84 × 11.9 × 12.1 inches
Weight not stated not stated 15.2 pounds not stated not stated not stated 11.8 pounds not stated not stated not stated 17.8 pounds
Size 44 Lbs not stated 26.5 Lbs 60lbs not stated not stated 26Lbs/24H 26 Lb 26lbs Medium 26.5lbs
Model SLIM41T-US-0610 HZB-12/Q SLIM01B not stated HZB-15NH/S EFIC128AMZBLACK HZB-12Q IGLICEBSC26BK CERI26B0ABB EFIC120-BLKSS-SC ICM1258S

Is a countertop ice maker worth it?

A countertop machine is worth it when your freezer can't keep up or you buy bagged ice every week. It needs no plumbing, but it also keeps nothing frozen: Frigidaire says outright that ice should go to the freezer soon after it is made.

Worth it if

  • You host often or fill coolers
  • Your fridge has no ice maker
  • You want ice in an RV, office or dorm

Skip it if

  • You want ice stored for days
  • You have no counter space near an outlet

How these countertop picks were chosen

Each pick is a countertop ice maker whose Amazon listing we read for output, batch time, tank size, noise and cleaning; none was used by us. The Silonn SLIM01 is also sold in steel, but it is the same machine as the black SLIM01B, so it is counted once at the lower price. Prices and stock move daily.

How to choose a countertop ice maker

  1. Decide on ice type

    Bullet makers are cheap and quick. Nugget makers make soft, chewable ice and cost roughly twice as much or more.

  2. Size the output

    Most bullet picks list 26 lb a day. The nugget picks run from 35 to 60 lb.

  3. Check the height

    Frigidaire EFIC120 and EFIC128 are 14.5 inches tall in their specs; the Crzoe is about 10.4 inches.

  4. Watch the power draw

    Frigidaire lists 105W for the EFIC128 and Igloo 120W, useful if you run off an inverter.

  5. Cleaning

    Most picks have a button-started clean cycle. The Frigidaire EFIC120 relies on a drain plug and the Igloo lists no clean cycle.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best countertop ice maker?

The Silonn SLIM41T nugget maker, for its 44 lb rating, 3L tank and app control.

What is the cheapest countertop ice maker here?

The red Crzoe bullet ice maker.

Do countertop ice makers need a water line?

No. All of these run from a tank you fill by hand.

Do they keep ice frozen?

No. Melted ice drains back into the tank and is made into new ice.

Which uses the least power?

The Frigidaire EFIC128 lists 105W, the lowest figure given here.

See also