As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

7 Best Freezers with Manual Defrost, Compared

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

Manual defrost freezers skip the fan and heater cycle of frost-free models, so they cost less and hold a steadier temperature; the trade is chipping out frost a few times a year. Our top pick is the BLACK+DECKER BCFK516, a 5.0 cu ft chest that holds about 175 lb of food, sets its temperature from an outside dial with an indicator light, and drains through an easy-access plug. The other 7 picks run from a 1.1 cu ft upright to a 19.8 cu ft chest, chosen from listings and published specs.

Our top pick: BLACK+DECKER 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1 BLACK+DECKER 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Best overall Most households Check price of BLACK+DECKER 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer on Amazon
2 Novadexor 3.5 Cu. Ft. Black Chest Freezer Best budget Tight budgets Check price of Novadexor 3.5 Cu. Ft. Black Chest Freezer on Amazon
3 Koolatron 3.5 Cu. Ft. Compact Chest Freezer Best stay-open lid Compact spaces Check price of Koolatron 3.5 Cu. Ft. Compact Chest Freezer on Amazon
4 Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Best mid-size chest Bulk storage Check price of Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer on Amazon
5 BLACK+DECKER 19.8 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Best large capacity Big households Check price of BLACK+DECKER 19.8 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer on Amazon
6 Hamilton Beach 11 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer Best upright Organized storage Check price of Hamilton Beach 11 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer on Amazon
7 Frigidaire 1.1 Cu Ft Upright Freezer Best mini Small spaces Check price of Frigidaire 1.1 Cu Ft Upright Freezer on Amazon

The best fit for you

Our 7 picks

Best overall

BLACK+DECKER 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer

Best for: Most households

Defrost Type
Manual Defrost (what this guide is about)
Total Capacity
5.1 Cu. Ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Temperature Control
Mechanical control dial
Interior Organization
Removable storage basket
Features
Freezer

View on Amazon: BLACK+DECKER 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link

BLACK+DECKER's BCFK516 is a white 5.0 cu ft chest that holds about 175 lb of frozen food. Its mechanical dial and indicator light sit outside, so you adjust it without opening the lid, and the manual defrost drains through an easy-access plug. A removable basket is included. 27.8 x 21.7 x 33.5 in, 52.9 lb.

Pros

  • BCFK516 outside dial
  • Easy-access drain
  • 175 lb load

Cons

  • BCFK516 no temperature range listed
  • One basket

Good fit if

  • Families adding storage
  • Kitchens and basements

Skip if

  • Very small spaces
  • Frost-free seekers

Verdict: The BCFK516 is the best manual defrost freezer overall.

Best budget

Novadexor 3.5 Cu. Ft. Black Chest Freezer

Best for: Tight budgets

Defrost Type
Manual Defrost (what this guide is about)
Total Capacity
3.5 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Temperature Control
Mechanical thermostat
Door Configuration
Top-opening lid
Interior Organization
Removable wire basket

View on Amazon: Novadexor 3.5 Cu. Ft. Black Chest Freezer Affiliate link

Novadexor's 1107cc is a black 3.5 cu ft chest with compressor cooling to 0 F, a mechanical thermostat dial, a PCM steel lid and a removable wire basket. Defrosting drains through a bottom plug; it needs 110V/60Hz. 20.5 x 16.1 x 30.5 in, 38.5 lb.

Pros

  • Novadexor 1107cc lowest price
  • Bottom drain plug
  • Under 21 in wide

Cons

  • 1107cc rated only to 0 F
  • Basic dial

Good fit if

  • Apartments
  • Small extra storage

Skip if

  • Long-term deep freezing
  • Large families

Verdict: The Novadexor 1107cc is the budget manual defrost pick.

Best stay-open lid

Koolatron 3.5 Cu. Ft. Compact Chest Freezer

Best for: Compact spaces

Defrost Type
Manual Defrost (what this guide is about)
Total Capacity
3.5 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Temperature Control
External temperature control dial
Door Configuration
Stay-open lid
Interior Organization
Removable wire basket

View on Amazon: Koolatron 3.5 Cu. Ft. Compact Chest Freezer Affiliate link

Koolatron's KTCF99 is a 3.5 cu ft (99 L) flat-back chest with a front-mounted drain and leak-proof plug. Its lid opens one-handed and stays open, rear hinges keep it off the wall, and an external dial holds 32 to -11.2 F. A vinyl-coated hanging basket is included. 20.8 x 22.3 x 33.3 in.

Pros

  • KTCF99 stay-open lid
  • Front drain
  • 32 to -11.2 F dial

Cons

  • KTCF99 weight not listed
  • One basket

Good fit if

  • Against a wall
  • Garages and dorms

Skip if

  • Shelf storage
  • Bulk buyers

Verdict: The KTCF99 is the pick for easy loading.

Best mid-size chest

Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer

Best for: Bulk storage

Defrost Type
Manual Defrost (what this guide is about)
Total Capacity
8.7 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Temperature Control
External dial, 7 settings
Door Configuration
Stay-open lid
Interior Organization
1 removable hanging basket

View on Amazon: Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link

Kenmore's KKCF8.7-W is an 8.7 cu ft (246 L) ivory chest for garages and cabins. Easy-move rollers and a front drain with a leakproof plug make defrosting simpler, the balanced hinge lid stays open at several angles, and a hanging basket keeps small items on top. 37.6 x 24.2 x 33.5 in, 70.5 lb.

Pros

  • KKCF8.7-W rollers
  • Front drain
  • Multi-angle lid

Cons

  • KKCF8.7-W no temperature range listed
  • 37.6 in wide

Good fit if

  • Hunters and bulk buyers
  • Unheated garages

Skip if

  • Small rooms
  • Frost-free seekers

Verdict: The KKCF8.7-W is the mid-size chest pick.

Best large capacity

BLACK+DECKER 19.8 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer

Best for: Big households

Defrost Type
Manual Defrost (what this guide is about)
Total Capacity
19.8 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Temperature Control
Mechanical temperature control dial
Door Configuration
Top opening
Interior Organization
2 removable storage baskets

View on Amazon: BLACK+DECKER 19.8 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link

BLACK+DECKER's BCF1980E is a 19.8 cu ft white chest using R600a refrigerant, with two removable baskets, an outside mechanical dial with indicator lights and a manual defrost drain. It is 71 x 29.5 x 33.5 in, so it needs a long wall.

Pros

  • BCF1980E 19.8 cu ft
  • Two baskets
  • Outside dial

Cons

  • BCF1980E 71 in wide
  • Weight not listed

Good fit if

  • Large families
  • Garage stockpiles

Skip if

  • Apartments
  • Narrow rooms

Verdict: The BCF1980E is the large-capacity pick.

Best upright

Hamilton Beach 11 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer

Best for: Organized storage

Total Capacity
11 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Upright
Defrost Type
Manual
Interior Organization
7 clear plastic drawer compartments
Features
Freezer
Dimensions
26 × 68 × 26 inches

View on Amazon: Hamilton Beach 11 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer Affiliate link

Hamilton Beach's HBFRF1115 is an 11 cu ft stainless upright with seven clear plastic drawers, a flush back, a front-leveling stance and an easy-grasp handle. Defrost is manual and the temperature is adjustable. The title gives 25 x 23.6 x 66.5 in, while the spec fields read differently; weight 110 lb.

Pros

  • HBFRF1115 seven drawers
  • Upright access
  • Stainless finish

Cons

  • HBFRF1115 dimension fields conflict
  • Manual defrost in an upright

Good fit if

  • Meal preppers
  • Kitchens and basements

Skip if

  • Frost-free seekers
  • Short spaces

Verdict: The HBFRF1115 is the upright manual defrost pick.

Best mini

Frigidaire 1.1 Cu Ft Upright Freezer

Best for: Small spaces

Total Capacity
1 cu ft
Form Factor
Upright
Defrost Type
Manual
Door Configuration
Reversible door
Features
Freezer, Reversible Door
Application
Kitchen, Dorm, RV

View on Amazon: Frigidaire 1.1 Cu Ft Upright Freezer Affiliate link

Frigidaire's EFRF1146-COM is a 1.1 cu ft silver cube with six vinyl-coated wire shelves, a flush back, a recessed handle and a reversible door, sized for RVs, dorms and offices. Defrost is manual. 19 x 20 x 21 in, 34.1 lb.

Pros

  • EFRF1146-COM six shelves
  • Reversible door
  • Fits RVs

Cons

  • EFRF1146-COM 1.1 cu ft
  • No range listed

Good fit if

  • Dorms and offices
  • RVs

Skip if

  • Bulk storage
  • Families

Verdict: The EFRF1146-COM is the mini pick.

Specifications side by side

Spec BLACK+DECKER 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Novadexor 3.5 Cu. Ft. Black Chest Freezer Koolatron 3.5 Cu. Ft. Compact Chest Freezer Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer BLACK+DECKER 19.8 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Hamilton Beach 11 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer Frigidaire 1.1 Cu Ft Upright Freezer
Total Capacity 5.1 Cu. Ft. 3.5 cu. ft. 3.5 cu. ft. 8.7 cu. ft. 19.8 cu. ft. 11 cu. ft. 1 cu ft
Form Factor Chest Chest Chest Chest Chest Upright Upright
Defrost Type Manual Manual Manual Manual Manual defrost Manual Manual
Temperature Control Mechanical control dial Mechanical thermostat External temperature control dial External dial, 7 settings Mechanical temperature control dial not stated not stated
Door Configuration not stated Top-opening lid Stay-open lid Stay-open lid Top opening not stated Reversible door
Interior Organization Removable storage basket Removable wire basket Removable wire basket 1 removable hanging basket 2 removable storage baskets 7 clear plastic drawer compartments not stated
Features Freezer Freezer Freezer Freezer Freezer Freezer Freezer, Reversible Door
Cooling Type not stated Compressor not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated
Application not stated Home, Garage Home, Dorm, Garage, Apartment Home, Dorm, Garage, Apartment not stated not stated Kitchen, Dorm, RV
Color White Black White Ivory White White STAINLESS Silver
Voltage not stated 110V not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated
Placement not stated not stated Basement Basement not stated not stated not stated
Dimensions 21.7 × 27.8 × 33.5 inches 16.1 × 20.5 × 30.5 inches 22.3 × 20.8 × 33.3 inches 24.2 × 37.6 × 33.5 inches 29.5 × 71 × 33.5 inches 26 × 68 × 26 inches 20 × 19 × 21 inches
Weight 52.9 pounds 38.5 pounds not stated 70.5 pounds not stated 110 pounds 34.1 pounds
Size 5.0 Cu. Ft. 3.5 Cu Ft 3.5 Cubic Feet 8.7 Cu Ft 19.8 Cu. Ft. 11 CU FT 1.1 cu ft
Model BCFK516 1107cc KTCF99 KKCF8.7-W BCF1980E HBFRF1115 EFRF1146-COM

How to choose a manual defrost freezer

  1. Chest for long storage, upright for daily use

    The chests here (3.5 to 19.8 cu ft) hold cold longer with the lid shut; the Hamilton Beach and Frigidaire uprights put food at eye level on drawers or shelves.

  2. Check the drain

    Front drains on the BLACK+DECKER, Koolatron and Kenmore chests let meltwater run into a pan without tipping the cabinet.

  3. Mind the footprint

    The BCF1980E is 71 in wide; the Novadexor and Koolatron 3.5 cu ft chests stay under 21 in.

  4. Defrost when frost reaches about a quarter inch

    Thicker frost cuts usable space and makes the compressor work harder, so plan a defrost before a big shopping trip.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best manual defrost freezer?

The BLACK+DECKER BCFK516: a 5.0 cu ft chest holding about 175 lb, with an outside dial, indicator light and easy-access drain.

What is the cheapest manual defrost freezer here?

The Novadexor 1107cc 3.5 cu ft black chest with a mechanical thermostat and bottom drain plug.

Is there a manual defrost upright freezer?

Yes: the Hamilton Beach HBFRF1115 (11 cu ft, 7 drawers) and the Frigidaire EFRF1146-COM (1.1 cu ft).

Which manual defrost freezer is largest?

The BLACK+DECKER BCF1980E at 19.8 cu ft, with two removable baskets.

Why choose manual defrost over frost free?

Manual defrost models cost less and avoid the warm-up cycles frost-free units use, which suits long-term storage of meat.

See also