As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

Best Freezers: 5 Chest and Upright Picks Compared

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

The first choice is the type: a chest freezer holds more per dollar, an upright keeps food on shelves at eye level. Our top pick is the Frigidaire EFRF5003, a garage-ready 5.0 cu ft chest with a 7-setting thermostat knob, an aluminum liner, a removable basket and an exterior defrost drain. If you never want to defrost by hand, the BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW is the frost-free upright here. We compared 5 freezers using listings and published specs.

Our top pick: Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1 Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer Best overall Most buyers Check price of Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer on Amazon
2 BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer Best frost free No-defrost buyers Check price of BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer on Amazon
3 Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Best large chest Bulk storage Check price of Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer on Amazon
4 Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer Best compact upright Shared homes Check price of Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer on Amazon
5 Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light Best with LED light Kitchens and bars Check price of Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light on Amazon

The best fit for you

Our 5 picks

Best overall

Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer

Best for: Most buyers

Features
✓ Freezer, Adjustable Thermostat
Total Capacity
5.0 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Door Configuration
Top door
Interior Organization
Removable vinyl-coated wire basket
Application
Garage

View on Amazon: Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer Affiliate link

Frigidaire's EFRF5003 is a black 5.0 cu ft chest, garage-ready, with an adjustable thermostat knob of 7 settings and a power-on light. A removable vinyl-coated wire basket, an aluminum interior liner and an exterior defrost drain are listed; 28 x 23 x 35 in.

Pros

  • EFRF5003 lowest price here
  • Garage-ready
  • Exterior drain

Cons

  • EFRF5003 one basket
  • No degree range listed

Good fit if

  • Garages
  • Family overflow

Skip if

  • Buyers wanting shelves
  • Tiny rooms

Verdict: The EFRF5003 is the best freezer for most homes.

Best frost free

BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer

Best for: No-defrost buyers

Features
✓ Freezer, Convertible
Total Capacity
14 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Upright
Defrost Type
Frost-Free
Temperature Control
Electronic control with LED display
Interior Organization
Glass shelves

View on Amazon: BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer Affiliate link

BLACK+DECKER's BUC1400XW is a 14 cu ft white upright with glass shelves that also converts to a full-size refrigerator. It is frost free, Energy Star rated, uses an electronic control with LED display and has a Sabbath mode; 28 x 27.9 x 68.1 in and 157 lb.

Pros

  • BUC1400XW frost free
  • Converts to a fridge
  • Sabbath mode

Cons

  • BUC1400XW 68.1 in tall
  • 157 lb

Good fit if

  • Large families
  • Garages with power

Skip if

  • Small apartments
  • Tight budgets

Verdict: The BUC1400XW is the frost-free pick.

Best large chest

Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer

Best for: Bulk storage

Features
✓ Freezer
Total Capacity
8.7 cu. ft.
Form Factor
Chest
Defrost Type
Manual
Temperature Control
External dial, 7 settings
Door Configuration
Stay-open lid

View on Amazon: Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link

Read our full review

Kenmore's KKCF8.7 is an 8.7 cu ft (246 L) white chest with a balanced lid that stays open at several angles, a hanging basket, rollers and a front drain with a leakproof plug. An external dial has 7 settings from 10 to -11 F, it is built for unheated garages or cabins, and Kenmore lists a 2-year warranty.

Pros

  • KKCF8.7 2-year warranty
  • Rollers
  • Front drain

Cons

  • KKCF8.7 37.6 in wide
  • Manual defrost

Good fit if

  • Hunters and bulk buyers
  • Garages and cabins

Skip if

  • Small kitchens
  • Upright fans

Verdict: The KKCF8.7 is the large chest pick.

Best compact upright

Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer

Best for: Shared homes

Features
✓ Freezer, Lock, Reversible Door, Adjustable Thermostat, Convertible
Total Capacity
3.1 Cu Ft
Form Factor
Upright
Defrost Type
Manual
Temperature Control
Adjustable thermostat
Door Configuration
Reversible door

View on Amazon: Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer Affiliate link

Whynter's CUF-301BK is a 3.1 cu ft black upright with a stainless door, 20 x 21 x 34 in and 50.5 lb. A keyed cylinder lock holds the door, the recessed-handle door can be hung from either side, and a removable slide-out shelf and manual defrost are listed. Energy Star is in the title.

Pros

  • CUF-301BK keyed lock
  • Reversible door
  • Energy Star

Cons

  • CUF-301BK manual defrost
  • Price high for 3.1 cu ft

Good fit if

  • Shared apartments
  • Home offices

Skip if

  • Bulk buyers
  • Budget shoppers

Verdict: The CUF-301BK is the compact upright pick.

Best with LED light

Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light

Best for: Kitchens and bars

Features
✓ Freezer, Interior LED Light
Total Capacity
5.1 Cu.ft
Form Factor
Chest
Defrost Type
Manual
Temperature Control
7 adjustable settings
Door Configuration
Top-open

View on Amazon: Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light Affiliate link

Read our full review

Uthfy's HE-150 is a white 5.1 cu ft chest, 24.9 x 21.8 x 33.5 in, with 7 settings from 17.6 to -18.4 F. It runs below 40 dB, has two detachable baskets and an interior LED light, and drains through a bottom plug when frost reaches about 1/8 in.

Pros

  • HE-150 -18.4 F low end
  • LED light
  • Two baskets

Cons

  • HE-150 manual defrost
  • Less known brand

Good fit if

  • Kitchens
  • Garages and bars

Skip if

  • Upright fans
  • Frost-free seekers

Verdict: The HE-150 is the pick for a lit chest.

Specifications side by side

Spec Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light
Total Capacity 5.0 cu. ft. 14 cu. ft. 8.7 cu. ft. 3.1 Cu Ft 5.1 Cu.ft
Form Factor Chest Upright Chest Upright Chest
Defrost Type not stated Frost-Free Manual Manual Manual
Temperature Control not stated Electronic control with LED display External dial, 7 settings Adjustable thermostat 7 adjustable settings
Door Configuration Top door not stated Stay-open lid Reversible door Top-open
Interior Organization Removable vinyl-coated wire basket Glass shelves 1 removable hanging basket Removable slide-out shelf 2 detachable storage baskets
Features Freezer, Adjustable Thermostat Freezer, Convertible Freezer Freezer, Lock, Reversible Door, Adjustable Thermostat, Convertible Freezer, Interior LED Light
Application Garage not stated Home, Dorm, Garage, Apartment Home Home, Bar, Kitchen, Garage
Color Black White Ivory White Black White
Room not stated not stated not stated not stated Home Bar
Placement not stated not stated Basement not stated not stated
Dimensions 23 × 28 × 35 inches 27.9 × 28 × 68.1 inches 24.2 × 37.6 × 33.5 inches 21 × 20 × 34 inches 21.8 × 24.9 × 33.5 inches
Weight 35 pounds 157 pounds 70.5 pounds 50.5 pounds 55.6 pounds
Size 5 cu ft 14 Cu. Ft. 8.7 Cu Ft 3.1 Cubic Feet 5.1 Cu.ft
Model EFRF5003-BLACK BUC1400XW KKCF8.7-W CUF-301BK HE-150

Choosing between these freezers

  1. Pick the type first

    Choose a chest for bulk meat and long storage; choose an upright if you want to see everything without lifting baskets.

  2. Garage use

    Only buy for a garage if the listing says so: the Frigidaire EFRF5003 is garage-ready and the Kenmore is rated for unheated areas.

  3. Frost free or manual

    The BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW is frost free; the other four need defrosting by hand, with drains on the Frigidaire, Kenmore and Uthfy.

  4. Warranty

    Kenmore lists a 2-year warranty on the KKCF8.7, longer than most freezers here state.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best freezer overall?

The Frigidaire EFRF5003: a garage-ready 5.0 cu ft chest with 7 thermostat settings, an aluminum liner, a removable basket and an exterior defrost drain.

Should I buy a chest or an upright?

A chest holds more per dollar and keeps cold when opened; an upright such as the BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW or Whynter CUF-301BK keeps food on shelves.

Which freezer here is frost free?

Only the BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW, a 14 cu ft upright that also converts to a refrigerator and has a Sabbath mode.

Which freezer has the longest warranty?

The Kenmore KKCF8.7, with a 2-year warranty in its listing.

Which of these freezers lights up inside?

The Uthfy HE-150, a 5.1 cu ft chest with an LED light, two baskets and 7 settings down to -18.4 F.

See also