Best Freezers: 5 Chest and Upright Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The first choice is the type: a chest freezer holds more per dollar, an upright keeps food on shelves at eye level. Our top pick is the Frigidaire EFRF5003, a garage-ready 5.0 cu ft chest with a 7-setting thermostat knob, an aluminum liner, a removable basket and an exterior defrost drain. If you never want to defrost by hand, the BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW is the frost-free upright here. We compared 5 freezers using listings and published specs.
Our top pick: Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer Best overall | Most buyers | Check price of Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer on Amazon |
| 2 | BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer Best frost free | No-defrost buyers | Check price of BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer on Amazon |
| 3 | Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Best large chest | Bulk storage | Check price of Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer on Amazon |
| 4 | Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer Best compact upright | Shared homes | Check price of Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer on Amazon |
| 5 | Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light Best with LED light | Kitchens and bars | Check price of Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light on Amazon |
The best fit for you
- A garage-ready chest for most homes Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer EFRF5003: 5.0 cu ft, 7 settings, exterior drain.
- No manual defrosting BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer BUC1400XW: 14 cu ft, frost free, fridge mode.
- Bulk storage with a warranty Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer KKCF8.7: 8.7 cu ft, 10 to -11 F, 2-year warranty.
- A small upright with a lock Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer CUF-301BK: 3.1 cu ft, keyed lock, recessed handle.
- A chest with light and two baskets Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light HE-150: 5.1 cu ft, LED light, under 40 dB.
Our 5 picks
Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer
Best for: Most buyers
- Features
- ✓ Freezer, Adjustable Thermostat
- Total Capacity
- 5.0 cu. ft.
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Door Configuration
- Top door
- Interior Organization
- Removable vinyl-coated wire basket
- Application
- Garage
View on Amazon: Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer Affiliate link
Frigidaire's EFRF5003 is a black 5.0 cu ft chest, garage-ready, with an adjustable thermostat knob of 7 settings and a power-on light. A removable vinyl-coated wire basket, an aluminum interior liner and an exterior defrost drain are listed; 28 x 23 x 35 in.
Pros
- EFRF5003 lowest price here
- Garage-ready
- Exterior drain
Cons
- EFRF5003 one basket
- No degree range listed
Good fit if
- Garages
- Family overflow
Skip if
- Buyers wanting shelves
- Tiny rooms
Verdict: The EFRF5003 is the best freezer for most homes.
BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer
Best for: No-defrost buyers
- Features
- ✓ Freezer, Convertible
- Total Capacity
- 14 cu. ft.
- Form Factor
- Upright
- Defrost Type
- Frost-Free
- Temperature Control
- Electronic control with LED display
- Interior Organization
- Glass shelves
View on Amazon: BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer Affiliate link
BLACK+DECKER's BUC1400XW is a 14 cu ft white upright with glass shelves that also converts to a full-size refrigerator. It is frost free, Energy Star rated, uses an electronic control with LED display and has a Sabbath mode; 28 x 27.9 x 68.1 in and 157 lb.
Pros
- BUC1400XW frost free
- Converts to a fridge
- Sabbath mode
Cons
- BUC1400XW 68.1 in tall
- 157 lb
Good fit if
- Large families
- Garages with power
Skip if
- Small apartments
- Tight budgets
Verdict: The BUC1400XW is the frost-free pick.
Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
Best for: Bulk storage
- Features
- ✓ Freezer
- Total Capacity
- 8.7 cu. ft.
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Defrost Type
- Manual
- Temperature Control
- External dial, 7 settings
- Door Configuration
- Stay-open lid
View on Amazon: Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link
Kenmore's KKCF8.7 is an 8.7 cu ft (246 L) white chest with a balanced lid that stays open at several angles, a hanging basket, rollers and a front drain with a leakproof plug. An external dial has 7 settings from 10 to -11 F, it is built for unheated garages or cabins, and Kenmore lists a 2-year warranty.
Pros
- KKCF8.7 2-year warranty
- Rollers
- Front drain
Cons
- KKCF8.7 37.6 in wide
- Manual defrost
Good fit if
- Hunters and bulk buyers
- Garages and cabins
Skip if
- Small kitchens
- Upright fans
Verdict: The KKCF8.7 is the large chest pick.
Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer
Best for: Shared homes
- Features
- ✓ Freezer, Lock, Reversible Door, Adjustable Thermostat, Convertible
- Total Capacity
- 3.1 Cu Ft
- Form Factor
- Upright
- Defrost Type
- Manual
- Temperature Control
- Adjustable thermostat
- Door Configuration
- Reversible door
View on Amazon: Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer Affiliate link
Whynter's CUF-301BK is a 3.1 cu ft black upright with a stainless door, 20 x 21 x 34 in and 50.5 lb. A keyed cylinder lock holds the door, the recessed-handle door can be hung from either side, and a removable slide-out shelf and manual defrost are listed. Energy Star is in the title.
Pros
- CUF-301BK keyed lock
- Reversible door
- Energy Star
Cons
- CUF-301BK manual defrost
- Price high for 3.1 cu ft
Good fit if
- Shared apartments
- Home offices
Skip if
- Bulk buyers
- Budget shoppers
Verdict: The CUF-301BK is the compact upright pick.
Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light
Best for: Kitchens and bars
- Features
- ✓ Freezer, Interior LED Light
- Total Capacity
- 5.1 Cu.ft
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Defrost Type
- Manual
- Temperature Control
- 7 adjustable settings
- Door Configuration
- Top-open
View on Amazon: Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light Affiliate link
Uthfy's HE-150 is a white 5.1 cu ft chest, 24.9 x 21.8 x 33.5 in, with 7 settings from 17.6 to -18.4 F. It runs below 40 dB, has two detachable baskets and an interior LED light, and drains through a bottom plug when frost reaches about 1/8 in.
Pros
- HE-150 -18.4 F low end
- LED light
- Two baskets
Cons
- HE-150 manual defrost
- Less known brand
Good fit if
- Kitchens
- Garages and bars
Skip if
- Upright fans
- Frost-free seekers
Verdict: The HE-150 is the pick for a lit chest.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Frigidaire 5.0 Cu Ft Garage Chest Freezer | BLACK+DECKER 14 Cu. Ft. Convertible Upright Freezer | Koolatron 8.7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer | Whynter 3.1 Cu Ft Upright Mini Freezer | Uthfy 5.1 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer with LED Light |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Capacity | 5.0 cu. ft. | 14 cu. ft. | 8.7 cu. ft. | 3.1 Cu Ft | 5.1 Cu.ft |
| Form Factor | Chest | Upright | Chest | Upright | Chest |
| Defrost Type | not stated | Frost-Free | Manual | Manual | Manual |
| Temperature Control | not stated | Electronic control with LED display | External dial, 7 settings | Adjustable thermostat | 7 adjustable settings |
| Door Configuration | Top door | not stated | Stay-open lid | Reversible door | Top-open |
| Interior Organization | Removable vinyl-coated wire basket | Glass shelves | 1 removable hanging basket | Removable slide-out shelf | 2 detachable storage baskets |
| Features | Freezer, Adjustable Thermostat | Freezer, Convertible | Freezer | Freezer, Lock, Reversible Door, Adjustable Thermostat, Convertible | Freezer, Interior LED Light |
| Application | Garage | not stated | Home, Dorm, Garage, Apartment | Home | Home, Bar, Kitchen, Garage |
| Color | Black | White | Ivory White | Black | White |
| Room | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Home Bar |
| Placement | not stated | not stated | Basement | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 23 × 28 × 35 inches | 27.9 × 28 × 68.1 inches | 24.2 × 37.6 × 33.5 inches | 21 × 20 × 34 inches | 21.8 × 24.9 × 33.5 inches |
| Weight | 35 pounds | 157 pounds | 70.5 pounds | 50.5 pounds | 55.6 pounds |
| Size | 5 cu ft | 14 Cu. Ft. | 8.7 Cu Ft | 3.1 Cubic Feet | 5.1 Cu.ft |
| Model | EFRF5003-BLACK | BUC1400XW | KKCF8.7-W | CUF-301BK | HE-150 |
Choosing between these freezers
-
Pick the type first
Choose a chest for bulk meat and long storage; choose an upright if you want to see everything without lifting baskets.
-
Garage use
Only buy for a garage if the listing says so: the Frigidaire EFRF5003 is garage-ready and the Kenmore is rated for unheated areas.
-
Frost free or manual
The BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW is frost free; the other four need defrosting by hand, with drains on the Frigidaire, Kenmore and Uthfy.
-
Warranty
Kenmore lists a 2-year warranty on the KKCF8.7, longer than most freezers here state.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best freezer overall?
The Frigidaire EFRF5003: a garage-ready 5.0 cu ft chest with 7 thermostat settings, an aluminum liner, a removable basket and an exterior defrost drain.
Should I buy a chest or an upright?
A chest holds more per dollar and keeps cold when opened; an upright such as the BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW or Whynter CUF-301BK keeps food on shelves.
Which freezer here is frost free?
Only the BLACK+DECKER BUC1400XW, a 14 cu ft upright that also converts to a refrigerator and has a Sabbath mode.
Which freezer has the longest warranty?
The Kenmore KKCF8.7, with a 2-year warranty in its listing.
Which of these freezers lights up inside?
The Uthfy HE-150, a 5.1 cu ft chest with an LED light, two baskets and 7 settings down to -18.4 F.
See also
- best freezers for home
- best freezers for kitchen
- best freezers for dorm
- best ice makers under 150
- best ice makers under 200
- Best Ice Makers Under $300: 12 Spec-Based Picks
- 10 Best Ice Makers Under $500, Compared
- Best Ice Makers Under $1000 in 2026: 11 Picks Ranked by Specs
- JLab headphones
- best GABRYLLY gaming chairs




