10 Best Ice Makers Under $4000, Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Our top pick under $4000 is the Hoshizaki KM-231BAJ, a 24-inch crescent cuber that its listing rates at up to 213 lb a day at 70/50°F (147 lb at 90/70°F) with an 80 lb bin. The Scotsman CU50GA-1 gourmet cube unit is the cheapest of the 10 picks and fits a 15-inch gap. Scotsman also covers nugget ice, a pump-drain gourmet model and 30-inch machines rated at over 300 lb a day. Each pick is ranked from its Amazon listing; we have not installed or used these units.
Our top pick: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin.
Quick picks
The best fit for you
- You want high output from a 24-inch unit Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin Up to 213 lb a day of crescent cubes, 80 lb bin.
- You want gourmet cubes for the least money Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker The cheapest pick, 15 inches wide with a reversible door.
- Your customers ask for nugget ice Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker 99 lb a day of nugget ice in a 15-inch unit.
- There is no floor drain Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Gourmet cube unit with a pump drain, approved for outdoor use.
- You need the most ice and have 208V Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker 329 lb a day of small cubes into a 110 lb bin.
Our 10 picks
Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin
Best for: Restaurants
- Daily Ice Production
- up to 213 lb/24 hours
- Storage Capacity
- 80 lb
- Ice Type
- crescent
- Form Factor
- Built-In
- Features
- Storage Bin
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin Affiliate link
The Hoshizaki KM-231BAJ is a 24-inch air-cooled crescent cuber rated at up to 213 lb a day at 70/50°F and 147 lb at 90/70°F, with an 80 lb built-in bin and an ADA-compliant bin opening.
Pros
- Up to 213 lb a day
- 80 lb bin
- Runs on a standard 115V outlet
Cons
- Low stock
- 24 inches wide
Good fit if
- You run a restaurant bar
- You like crescent cubes
Skip if
- You have a 15-inch gap
- You want nugget ice
Verdict: The best mix of output and storage under $4000.
Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker
Best for: Home bars
- Daily Ice Production
- Up to 64 lbs
- Storage Capacity
- Up to 26 lbs
- Ice Type
- Gourmet cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Drain Type
- Gravity drain
- Features
- Storage Bin, Water Filter, Gravity Drain
View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Scotsman CU50GA-1 is a 15-inch undercounter gourmet cube machine making up to 64 lb a day at 70/50°F (44 lb at 90/70°F) into a 26 lb bin, with a reversible door and gravity drain.
Pros
- Lowest price here
- 15 inches wide
- Gourmet cubes
Cons
- Gravity drain only
- 26 lb bin
Good fit if
- You want premium cubes at home or a bar
- You have a floor drain
Skip if
- You need a pump
- You need volume
Verdict: Gourmet ice at the lowest price in this band.
Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker
Best for: Nugget ice service
- Daily Ice Production
- 99 lb/Day
- Storage Capacity
- 36 lb
- Ice Type
- Nugget
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Features
- Storage Bin
- Dimensions
- 24 × 15 × 38 inches
View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link
This Scotsman 15-inch nugget ice machine is rated at up to 99 lb a day (74 lb AHRI certified) into a 36 lb bin, with a stainless evaporator and auger and a self-contained condenser.
Pros
- Nugget ice
- 15-inch width
- Stainless auger
Cons
- Low stock
- Close to $4000
Good fit if
- You want chewable ice in a bar or clinic
- You have a narrow slot
Skip if
- You want hard cubes
- You need over 99 lb
Verdict: The commercial nugget pick.
Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker
Best for: Patios and islands
- Ice Type
- Gourmet cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Drain Type
- Pump drain
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Silver
- Dimensions
- 34.4 × 14.9 × 22 inches
View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Scotsman CU50PA-1A is a 14.9-inch gourmet cube undercounter machine with a pump drain, a power cord, a water-condition display and outdoor approval; it asks for a 15 amp circuit.
Pros
- Pump drain
- Outdoor approved
- Gourmet cubes
Cons
- Output not stated in this listing
- Needs a 15 amp circuit
Good fit if
- There is no floor drain
- It goes outdoors
Skip if
- You want listed output figures
- You have a gravity drain
Verdict: The no-floor-drain gourmet choice.
Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker
Best for: High-volume bars
- Daily Ice Production
- 329 lb/Day
- Storage Capacity
- 110 lb
- Ice Type
- Small Cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Features
- Storage Bin
- Dimensions
- 30 × 30 × 39.5 inches
View on Amazon: Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker Affiliate link
This 30-inch Scotsman undercounter ice maker makes up to 329 lb of small cubes a day into a 110 lb bin on 208V, with AutoAlert lights, WaterSense adaptive purge and NSF and ETL listings.
Pros
- 329 lb a day
- 110 lb bin
- WaterSense purge control
Cons
- 208V supply needed
- 230 lb
Good fit if
- You have 208V power
- You serve high volume
Skip if
- You only have 115V
- Space is tight
Verdict: The output leader, if your power supports it.
Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: Busy restaurants
- Daily Ice Production
- Up to 313 lb / day
- Storage Capacity
- 110 lb
- Ice Type
- Medium cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Features
- Storage Bin
- Placement
- Commercial Use
View on Amazon: Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Scotsman CU3030MA-1 is a 30-inch Prodigy undercounter machine producing up to 313 lb of medium cubes a day into a 110 lb bin, with AutoAlert lights and WaterSense adaptive purge.
Pros
- Up to 313 lb a day
- 110 lb bin
- Medium cubes
Cons
- 30 inches wide
- Low stock
Good fit if
- You want medium cubes in volume
- You have a 30-inch opening
Skip if
- You lack the width
- You want small cubes
Verdict: High volume, medium cubes.
Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker
Best for: Cafes
- Daily Ice Production
- up to 163 lb/24 hours
- Storage Capacity
- 78 lb
- Ice Type
- crescent
- Form Factor
- undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Hoshizaki KM-161BAJ is a 23.75-inch air-cooled crescent cuber rated at up to 163 lb a day at 70/50°F and 123 lb at 90/70°F, with a 78 lb bin and NSF, UL and cETLus listings.
Pros
- 78 lb bin
- Crescent cubes
- ADA compliant
Cons
- Low stock
- Less output than the KM-231BAJ
Good fit if
- You need about 120 to 160 lb a day
- You want Hoshizaki for less
Skip if
- You need over 160 lb
- You have a 15-inch gap
Verdict: A step down in output and price from the KM-231BAJ.
Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: Offices
- Daily Ice Production
- Up to 55 lb / 24 hours
- Storage Capacity
- 22 lb
- Ice Type
- Crescent, Top Hat style full cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Dimensions
- 14 × 31 × 22 inches
- Weight
- 55 pounds
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Hoshizaki AM50BAE-AD is a self-contained undercounter ice maker making up to 55 lb of top hat cubes a day at 70/50°F into a 22 lb bin, rated at 3.4 amps and ADA compliant.
Pros
- 55 lb weight listed
- Top hat cubes
- ADA compliant
Cons
- 22 lb bin
- Listing dimensions look inconsistent
Good fit if
- You need an ADA-height unit
- You want low amp draw
Skip if
- You need storage
- You want clear dimensions
Verdict: Small, efficient and accessible.
Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: Cocktail bars
- Daily Ice Production
- 35 lbs/day
- Ice Type
- Extra-large Cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Dimensions
- 28 × 18 × 38 inches
View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Scotsman SRCP035A-1SU Brilliance is a 15-inch air-cooled undercounter machine for extra-large cubes, rated at 35 lb a day; the listing gives few other details.
Pros
- Extra-large cubes
- 15-inch width
- Air cooled
Cons
- 35 lb a day
- Sparse listing details
- Low stock
Good fit if
- You serve spirits over big cubes
- You can confirm specs with the seller
Skip if
- You need volume
- You want full specs listed
Verdict: Big cubes, but check the details.
Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: Bar stations
- Daily Ice Production
- 74 lbs/day
- Storage Capacity
- 24 lbs
- Ice Type
- Gourmet cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Dimensions
- 15.2 × 23.6 × 28.9 inches
View on Amazon: Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Scotsman CU0515GA-1 is an air-cooled undercounter gourmet cube machine with a 24 lb bin and stainless steel build; its title says 74 lb a day and its specs say 80 lb.
Pros
- Gourmet cubes
- Energy-saving system
- Power cord install
Cons
- 24 lb bin
- Output listed two ways
- Low stock
Good fit if
- You want gourmet ice with more output than the CU50
- You have a bar station
Skip if
- You need storage
- You want the cheapest gourmet unit
Verdict: A gourmet option with a bit more output.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin | Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker | Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker | Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker | Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker | Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker | Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker | Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker | Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker | Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Daily Ice Production | up to 213 lb/24 hours | Up to 64 lbs | 99 lb/Day | not stated | 329 lb/Day | Up to 313 lb / day | up to 163 lb/24 hours | Up to 55 lb / 24 hours | 35 lbs/day | 74 lbs/day |
| Storage Capacity | 80 lb | Up to 26 lbs | 36 lb | not stated | 110 lb | 110 lb | 78 lb | 22 lb | not stated | 24 lbs |
| Ice Type | crescent | Gourmet cube | Nugget | Gourmet cube | Small Cube | Medium cube | crescent | Crescent, Top Hat style full cube | Extra-large Cube | Gourmet cube |
| Form Factor | not stated | Undercounter | Undercounter | Undercounter | Undercounter | Undercounter | undercounter | Undercounter | Undercounter | Undercounter |
| Drain Type | not stated | Gravity drain | not stated | Pump drain | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Features | Storage Bin | Storage Bin, Water Filter, Gravity Drain | Storage Bin | Drain Pump | Storage Bin | Storage Bin | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Cooling Type | Air-Cooled | not stated | not stated | Air-Cooled | not stated | not stated | Air-Cooled | not stated | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled |
| Color | Stainless Steel | not stated | not stated | Silver | not stated | not stated | Stainless Steel | not stated | Check Images | not stated |
| Placement | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Commercial Use | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 28 × 24 × 39 inches | not stated | 24 × 15 × 38 inches | 34.4 × 14.9 × 22 inches | 30 × 30 × 39.5 inches | 30 × 30 × 39.5 inches | 28.3 × 23.8 × 39 inches | 14 × 31 × 22 inches | 28 × 18 × 38 inches | 15.2 × 23.6 × 28.9 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 100 pounds | 108 pounds | 100 pounds | 230 pounds | not stated | not stated | 55 pounds | not stated | 140 pounds |
| Model | KM-231BAJ | CU50GA-1 | not stated | CU50PA-1A | not stated | CU3030MA-1 | 1145-00495 | not stated | SRCP035A-1SU | CU0515GA-1 |
| Size | not stated | Without Filtration | 99 lb / Day - 36 lb Storage | not stated | 329 lb / Day - 110 lb Storage - Small Cube - 208V | 300 lb / day | not stated | not stated | 28.00x18.00x38.00 | 80 lb / day |
Things to check first
These are commercial machines with real installation needs. Output ratings drop in warm rooms, and several units are low in stock.
- Ratings at 70/50°F are higher than real-world output in hot kitchens.
- The 329 lb Scotsman needs a 208V supply.
- The Scotsman Brilliance listing gives few details beyond 35 lb a day.
- The CU0515GA-1 is listed at 74 lb in the title and 80 lb in its specs.
If you also evaluate computer hardware specifications, you can compare component metrics for a gaming laptop under 4000 across similar performance benchmarks.
How this list came together
We kept ice makers on Amazon at $4000 or less and compared their specs and feature bullets; we did not test them. The CU50GA-1 had three listings and the CU50PA-1A had a filter bundle, so we kept one listing of each model. A Scotsman Brilliance 65 lb unit is out of stock and was removed. Prices and stock change frequently.
How to choose an ice maker under $4000
-
Use the lower rating
Hoshizaki gives two figures: 213 and 147 lb for the KM-231BAJ, 163 and 123 lb for the KM-161BAJ. Plan on the lower one in a warm room.
-
Match width to the opening
The CU50 models and the nugget Scotsman are about 15 inches wide, the Hoshizaki KM models about 24, and the 30-inch Scotsmans need a 30-inch gap.
-
Drain type matters
The CU50GA-1 uses a gravity drain; the CU50PA-1A pumps water out, so it can go where no floor drain exists.
-
Pick the cube
Hoshizaki makes crescents, the CU50 and CU0515 make gourmet cubes, the Prodigy models make medium or small cubes, and the Brilliance makes extra-large cubes.
-
Check the power
Most run on 115V, but the 329 lb Scotsman is a 208V model and the CU50PA-1A asks for a 15 amp circuit.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best ice maker under $4000?
The Hoshizaki KM-231BAJ crescent cuber, rated at up to 213 lb a day with an 80 lb bin.
What is the cheapest option here?
The Scotsman CU50GA-1 gourmet cube machine.
Is there a nugget machine?
Yes, the Scotsman 15-inch nugget unit rated at 99 lb a day, AHRI certified at 74 lb.
Which works without a floor drain?
The Scotsman CU50PA-1A, which has a pump drain.
Which is the highest-output model?
The 30-inch Scotsman small-cube model at 329 lb a day.








