As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

10 Best Ice Makers Under $4000, Compared

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

Our top pick under $4000 is the Hoshizaki KM-231BAJ, a 24-inch crescent cuber that its listing rates at up to 213 lb a day at 70/50°F (147 lb at 90/70°F) with an 80 lb bin. The Scotsman CU50GA-1 gourmet cube unit is the cheapest of the 10 picks and fits a 15-inch gap. Scotsman also covers nugget ice, a pump-drain gourmet model and 30-inch machines rated at over 300 lb a day. Each pick is ranked from its Amazon listing; we have not installed or used these units.

Our top pick: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin.

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1 Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin Best overall Restaurants Check price of Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin on Amazon
2 Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Best budget Home bars Check price of Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker on Amazon
3 Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker Best nugget Nugget ice service Check price of Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker on Amazon
4 Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Best pump drain Patios and islands Check price of Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker on Amazon
5 Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker Highest output High-volume bars Check price of Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker on Amazon
6 Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker Also great Busy restaurants Check price of Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker on Amazon
7 Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker Also great Cafes Check price of Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker on Amazon
8 Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker Lightest unit Offices Check price of Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker on Amazon
9 Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker Best extra-large cubes Cocktail bars Check price of Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker on Amazon
10 Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker Also great Bar stations Check price of Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker on Amazon

The best fit for you

Our 10 picks

Best overall

Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin

Best for: Restaurants

Daily Ice Production
up to 213 lb/24 hours
Storage Capacity
80 lb
Ice Type
crescent
Form Factor
Built-In
Features
Storage Bin
Cooling Type
Air-Cooled

View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin Affiliate link

The Hoshizaki KM-231BAJ is a 24-inch air-cooled crescent cuber rated at up to 213 lb a day at 70/50°F and 147 lb at 90/70°F, with an 80 lb built-in bin and an ADA-compliant bin opening.

Pros

  • Up to 213 lb a day
  • 80 lb bin
  • Runs on a standard 115V outlet

Cons

  • Low stock
  • 24 inches wide

Good fit if

  • You run a restaurant bar
  • You like crescent cubes

Skip if

  • You have a 15-inch gap
  • You want nugget ice

Verdict: The best mix of output and storage under $4000.

Best budget

Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker

Best for: Home bars

Daily Ice Production
Up to 64 lbs
Storage Capacity
Up to 26 lbs
Ice Type
Gourmet cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Drain Type
Gravity drain
Features
Storage Bin, Water Filter, Gravity Drain

View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Scotsman CU50GA-1 is a 15-inch undercounter gourmet cube machine making up to 64 lb a day at 70/50°F (44 lb at 90/70°F) into a 26 lb bin, with a reversible door and gravity drain.

Pros

  • Lowest price here
  • 15 inches wide
  • Gourmet cubes

Cons

  • Gravity drain only
  • 26 lb bin

Good fit if

  • You want premium cubes at home or a bar
  • You have a floor drain

Skip if

  • You need a pump
  • You need volume

Verdict: Gourmet ice at the lowest price in this band.

Best nugget

Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: Nugget ice service

Daily Ice Production
99 lb/Day
Storage Capacity
36 lb
Ice Type
Nugget
Form Factor
Undercounter
Features
Storage Bin
Dimensions
24 × 15 × 38 inches

View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

This Scotsman 15-inch nugget ice machine is rated at up to 99 lb a day (74 lb AHRI certified) into a 36 lb bin, with a stainless evaporator and auger and a self-contained condenser.

Pros

  • Nugget ice
  • 15-inch width
  • Stainless auger

Cons

  • Low stock
  • Close to $4000

Good fit if

  • You want chewable ice in a bar or clinic
  • You have a narrow slot

Skip if

  • You want hard cubes
  • You need over 99 lb

Verdict: The commercial nugget pick.

Best pump drain

Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker

Best for: Patios and islands

Ice Type
Gourmet cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Drain Type
Pump drain
Cooling Type
Air-Cooled
Color
Silver
Dimensions
34.4 × 14.9 × 22 inches

View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Scotsman CU50PA-1A is a 14.9-inch gourmet cube undercounter machine with a pump drain, a power cord, a water-condition display and outdoor approval; it asks for a 15 amp circuit.

Pros

  • Pump drain
  • Outdoor approved
  • Gourmet cubes

Cons

  • Output not stated in this listing
  • Needs a 15 amp circuit

Good fit if

  • There is no floor drain
  • It goes outdoors

Skip if

  • You want listed output figures
  • You have a gravity drain

Verdict: The no-floor-drain gourmet choice.

Highest output

Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker

Best for: High-volume bars

Daily Ice Production
329 lb/Day
Storage Capacity
110 lb
Ice Type
Small Cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Features
Storage Bin
Dimensions
30 × 30 × 39.5 inches

View on Amazon: Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker Affiliate link

This 30-inch Scotsman undercounter ice maker makes up to 329 lb of small cubes a day into a 110 lb bin on 208V, with AutoAlert lights, WaterSense adaptive purge and NSF and ETL listings.

Pros

  • 329 lb a day
  • 110 lb bin
  • WaterSense purge control

Cons

  • 208V supply needed
  • 230 lb

Good fit if

  • You have 208V power
  • You serve high volume

Skip if

  • You only have 115V
  • Space is tight

Verdict: The output leader, if your power supports it.

Also great

Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker

Best for: Busy restaurants

Daily Ice Production
Up to 313 lb / day
Storage Capacity
110 lb
Ice Type
Medium cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Features
Storage Bin
Placement
Commercial Use

View on Amazon: Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Scotsman CU3030MA-1 is a 30-inch Prodigy undercounter machine producing up to 313 lb of medium cubes a day into a 110 lb bin, with AutoAlert lights and WaterSense adaptive purge.

Pros

  • Up to 313 lb a day
  • 110 lb bin
  • Medium cubes

Cons

  • 30 inches wide
  • Low stock

Good fit if

  • You want medium cubes in volume
  • You have a 30-inch opening

Skip if

  • You lack the width
  • You want small cubes

Verdict: High volume, medium cubes.

Also great

Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker

Best for: Cafes

Daily Ice Production
up to 163 lb/24 hours
Storage Capacity
78 lb
Ice Type
crescent
Form Factor
undercounter
Cooling Type
Air-Cooled
Color
Stainless Steel

View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Hoshizaki KM-161BAJ is a 23.75-inch air-cooled crescent cuber rated at up to 163 lb a day at 70/50°F and 123 lb at 90/70°F, with a 78 lb bin and NSF, UL and cETLus listings.

Pros

  • 78 lb bin
  • Crescent cubes
  • ADA compliant

Cons

  • Low stock
  • Less output than the KM-231BAJ

Good fit if

  • You need about 120 to 160 lb a day
  • You want Hoshizaki for less

Skip if

  • You need over 160 lb
  • You have a 15-inch gap

Verdict: A step down in output and price from the KM-231BAJ.

Lightest unit

Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker

Best for: Offices

Daily Ice Production
Up to 55 lb / 24 hours
Storage Capacity
22 lb
Ice Type
Crescent, Top Hat style full cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Dimensions
14 × 31 × 22 inches
Weight
55 pounds

View on Amazon: Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Hoshizaki AM50BAE-AD is a self-contained undercounter ice maker making up to 55 lb of top hat cubes a day at 70/50°F into a 22 lb bin, rated at 3.4 amps and ADA compliant.

Pros

  • 55 lb weight listed
  • Top hat cubes
  • ADA compliant

Cons

  • 22 lb bin
  • Listing dimensions look inconsistent

Good fit if

  • You need an ADA-height unit
  • You want low amp draw

Skip if

  • You need storage
  • You want clear dimensions

Verdict: Small, efficient and accessible.

Best extra-large cubes

Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker

Best for: Cocktail bars

Daily Ice Production
35 lbs/day
Ice Type
Extra-large Cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Cooling Type
Air-Cooled
Dimensions
28 × 18 × 38 inches

View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Scotsman SRCP035A-1SU Brilliance is a 15-inch air-cooled undercounter machine for extra-large cubes, rated at 35 lb a day; the listing gives few other details.

Pros

  • Extra-large cubes
  • 15-inch width
  • Air cooled

Cons

  • 35 lb a day
  • Sparse listing details
  • Low stock

Good fit if

  • You serve spirits over big cubes
  • You can confirm specs with the seller

Skip if

  • You need volume
  • You want full specs listed

Verdict: Big cubes, but check the details.

Also great

Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker

Best for: Bar stations

Daily Ice Production
74 lbs/day
Storage Capacity
24 lbs
Ice Type
Gourmet cube
Form Factor
Undercounter
Cooling Type
Air-Cooled
Dimensions
15.2 × 23.6 × 28.9 inches

View on Amazon: Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link

The Scotsman CU0515GA-1 is an air-cooled undercounter gourmet cube machine with a 24 lb bin and stainless steel build; its title says 74 lb a day and its specs say 80 lb.

Pros

  • Gourmet cubes
  • Energy-saving system
  • Power cord install

Cons

  • 24 lb bin
  • Output listed two ways
  • Low stock

Good fit if

  • You want gourmet ice with more output than the CU50
  • You have a bar station

Skip if

  • You need storage
  • You want the cheapest gourmet unit

Verdict: A gourmet option with a bit more output.

Specifications side by side

Spec Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker with Storage Bin Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Scotsman 30-Inch Undercounter Small Cube Ice Maker Scotsman 30-Inch Medium Cube Undercounter Ice Maker Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker Hoshizaki ADA Compliant Undercounter Ice Maker Scotsman 15-Inch Panel-Ready Undercounter Ice Maker Scotsman 80 lb Day Undercounter Ice Maker
Daily Ice Production up to 213 lb/24 hours Up to 64 lbs 99 lb/Day not stated 329 lb/Day Up to 313 lb / day up to 163 lb/24 hours Up to 55 lb / 24 hours 35 lbs/day 74 lbs/day
Storage Capacity 80 lb Up to 26 lbs 36 lb not stated 110 lb 110 lb 78 lb 22 lb not stated 24 lbs
Ice Type crescent Gourmet cube Nugget Gourmet cube Small Cube Medium cube crescent Crescent, Top Hat style full cube Extra-large Cube Gourmet cube
Form Factor not stated Undercounter Undercounter Undercounter Undercounter Undercounter undercounter Undercounter Undercounter Undercounter
Drain Type not stated Gravity drain not stated Pump drain not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated
Features Storage Bin Storage Bin, Water Filter, Gravity Drain Storage Bin Drain Pump Storage Bin Storage Bin not stated not stated not stated not stated
Cooling Type Air-Cooled not stated not stated Air-Cooled not stated not stated Air-Cooled not stated Air-Cooled Air-Cooled
Color Stainless Steel not stated not stated Silver not stated not stated Stainless Steel not stated Check Images not stated
Placement not stated not stated not stated not stated not stated Commercial Use not stated not stated not stated not stated
Dimensions 28 × 24 × 39 inches not stated 24 × 15 × 38 inches 34.4 × 14.9 × 22 inches 30 × 30 × 39.5 inches 30 × 30 × 39.5 inches 28.3 × 23.8 × 39 inches 14 × 31 × 22 inches 28 × 18 × 38 inches 15.2 × 23.6 × 28.9 inches
Weight not stated 100 pounds 108 pounds 100 pounds 230 pounds not stated not stated 55 pounds not stated 140 pounds
Model KM-231BAJ CU50GA-1 not stated CU50PA-1A not stated CU3030MA-1 1145-00495 not stated SRCP035A-1SU CU0515GA-1
Size not stated Without Filtration 99 lb / Day - 36 lb Storage not stated 329 lb / Day - 110 lb Storage - Small Cube - 208V 300 lb / day not stated not stated 28.00x18.00x38.00 80 lb / day

Things to check first

These are commercial machines with real installation needs. Output ratings drop in warm rooms, and several units are low in stock.

  • Ratings at 70/50°F are higher than real-world output in hot kitchens.
  • The 329 lb Scotsman needs a 208V supply.
  • The Scotsman Brilliance listing gives few details beyond 35 lb a day.
  • The CU0515GA-1 is listed at 74 lb in the title and 80 lb in its specs.

How this list came together

We kept ice makers on Amazon at $4000 or less and compared their specs and feature bullets; we did not test them. The CU50GA-1 had three listings and the CU50PA-1A had a filter bundle, so we kept one listing of each model. A Scotsman Brilliance 65 lb unit is out of stock and was removed. Prices and stock change frequently.

How to choose an ice maker under $4000

  1. Use the lower rating

    Hoshizaki gives two figures: 213 and 147 lb for the KM-231BAJ, 163 and 123 lb for the KM-161BAJ. Plan on the lower one in a warm room.

  2. Match width to the opening

    The CU50 models and the nugget Scotsman are about 15 inches wide, the Hoshizaki KM models about 24, and the 30-inch Scotsmans need a 30-inch gap.

  3. Drain type matters

    The CU50GA-1 uses a gravity drain; the CU50PA-1A pumps water out, so it can go where no floor drain exists.

  4. Pick the cube

    Hoshizaki makes crescents, the CU50 and CU0515 make gourmet cubes, the Prodigy models make medium or small cubes, and the Brilliance makes extra-large cubes.

  5. Check the power

    Most run on 115V, but the 329 lb Scotsman is a 208V model and the CU50PA-1A asks for a 15 amp circuit.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best ice maker under $4000?

The Hoshizaki KM-231BAJ crescent cuber, rated at up to 213 lb a day with an 80 lb bin.

What is the cheapest option here?

The Scotsman CU50GA-1 gourmet cube machine.

Is there a nugget machine?

Yes, the Scotsman 15-inch nugget unit rated at 99 lb a day, AHRI certified at 74 lb.

Which works without a floor drain?

The Scotsman CU50PA-1A, which has a pump drain.

Which is the highest-output model?

The 30-inch Scotsman small-cube model at 329 lb a day.

See also