6 Best Alternatives to the Manitowoc 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker (2026)

How alternatives compare to Manitowoc

VEVOR 66 lb Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker

The VEVOR 66 lb Nugget Ice Maker produces 66 lbs of ice daily, which is higher than the Manitowoc SM-50A’s 52 lbs. It makes nugget ice instead of octagon cubes, offering a different texture for drinks. The unit is wider at 16.5 inches compared to the 14.8-inch Manitowoc, so it may not fit standard 15-inch undercounter slots. It includes a drain pump and reversible door, adding installation flexibility. You should choose this if you need more daily production and prefer nugget ice over solid cubes. The extra width is the main trade-off for the increased capacity and different ice shape.

COTLIN 15-Inch Undercounter Bullet Ice Maker

The COTLIN 15-Inch Undercounter Bullet Ice Maker matches the Manitowoc’s 15-inch width, making it a direct fit for the same space. It produces bullet ice rather than octagon cubes, which some users find easier to drink. Like the Manitowoc, it includes a drain pump for flexible plumbing. However, it is slightly taller at 35 inches compared to the 33.5-inch Manitowoc. Storage capacity details are not provided in the data, so you cannot compare bin size directly. Pick this model if you need the same footprint but prefer bullet ice and can accommodate the extra inch of height. It is a solid choice for tight spaces with limited side ventilation.

EdgeStar 15-Inch Undercounter Clear Ice Maker

The EdgeStar IB450SSP 15-Inch Clear Ice Maker produces clear ice, which is distinct from the opaque octagon cubes of the Manitowoc. It is slightly narrower at 14.6 inches and shorter at 32.6 inches, fitting easily under counters. It includes a drain pump for installation flexibility. The data does not specify daily production or storage capacity, so you cannot compare volume directly. Choose this if you prioritize crystal-clear ice quality for cocktails or presentations. The smaller dimensions make it suitable for tighter built-in spaces. You give up the known 52 lbs daily production of the Manitowoc for the aesthetic benefit of clear ice and a more compact profile.

EUHOMY 110 lb Undercounter Ice Maker with Drain Pump

The EUHOMY 110 lb Undercounter Ice Maker offers significantly higher daily production than the Manitowoc’s 52 lbs. It makes hat cubes, which are different from octagon shapes. The unit is wider at 16.9 inches, so it does not fit the standard 15-inch undercounter slot. It includes a drain pump and storage bin for commercial or high-volume home use. You should pick this if you need double the ice production and can accommodate the extra width. The trade-off is the larger footprint and different cube shape. It is best suited for bars or cafes where volume matters more than fitting into a standard 15-inch cabinet space.

Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker

The Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker produces gourmet cubes, which are precise and distinct from the octagon ice of the Manitowoc. It matches the 15-inch width, fitting the same undercounter space. It includes a drain pump for flexible installation. The unit is heavier at 105 pounds compared to the 114-pound Manitowoc, though weight is not a functional difference. Daily production is listed as 65 lbs, which is higher than the Manitowoc’s 52 lbs. Choose this if you need higher production and prefer gourmet cube quality. It is ideal for bars and compact kitchens where cube precision and flexible drainage are priorities over the specific octagon shape.

EUHOMY 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker

The EUHOMY 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker produces 100 lbs of ice daily, nearly double the Manitowoc’s 52 lbs. It matches the 15-inch width, fitting the same undercounter space. It includes a drain pump for installation flexibility. The unit is slightly taller at 33.6 inches compared to the 33.5-inch Manitowoc, a negligible difference for most installations. The data does not specify ice shape, so you cannot compare cube types directly. Pick this if you need high-volume production and can fit it in a 15-inch slot. It is a strong choice for users who prioritize daily output over the specific octagon cube shape of the Manitowoc.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Manitowoc 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker with Drain Pump

Best for: high-volume undercounter ice needs

Daily Ice Production

52 lbs. per 24 hours

Storage Capacity

25 lb.

Ice Type

Octagon cubes

Form Factor

Undercounter

Drain Type

Pump kit

Features

Drain Pump

View on Amazon: Manitowoc 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker with Drain Pump Affiliate link

This undercounter ice maker produces 52 pounds of octagon cubes daily with a 25-pound storage bin. The stainless steel build measures 14.8 inches wide and includes a pump drain kit for flexibility. It suits you if you need reliable commercial-grade production in a tight space without requiring a gravity drain.

Pros

• Produces 52 lbs of ice per 24 hours
• Includes pump drain kit for flexible installation
• Stainless steel construction for durability

Cons

• 25 lb storage capacity is smaller than some competitors
• Heavier build at 114 lbs
• Limited to 1-3/8 inch octagon cube size

Good fit if

• You need high daily ice production
• You lack a gravity drain option
• You prefer stainless steel durability

Skip if

• You require nugget ice
• You need a larger storage bin
• You want a lighter unit

Verdict: Manitowoc SM-50A Undercounter Ice Maker fits you if you prioritize consistent 52 lb daily production and flexible drainage over compact storage.

2 Also great

VEVOR 66 lb Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: high-volume nugget ice needs

Daily Ice Production

66 Lbs/Day

Storage Capacity

18 lbs

Ice Type

nugget ice

Form Factor

undercounter, freestanding, or built-in

Drain Type

Drain Pump

Features

Drain Pump, Reversible Door

View on Amazon: VEVOR 66 lb Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

This VEVOR undercounter ice maker produces 66 pounds of nugget ice daily with an 18-pound storage bin. It includes a drain pump for flexible placement and a reversible door for left or right hinge installation. The unit measures 15 inches wide and 32.5 inches high. It suits you if you need high-volume nugget ice for home or small commercial use.

Pros

• Produces 66 pounds of nugget ice per day
• Includes an electric drain pump for flexible installation
• Features a reversible stainless steel door
• Triple-layer insulation for cold retention

Cons

• 18-pound storage capacity is smaller than some competitors
• 16.5-inch width is wider than the standard 15-inch slot
• Drain pump ships in a separate package

Good fit if

• You need high-volume nugget ice for parties
• You require flexible drainage options without gravity
• You want a reversible door for tight spaces

Skip if

• You need a standard 15-inch wide unit
• You prefer crescent or cube ice over nugget
• You want all components to arrive together

Verdict: VEVOR 66 lb Nugget Ice Maker delivers fast ice production and flexible drainage, making it a solid choice for users who need nugget ice and do not mind the extra width.

3 Also great

COTLIN 15-Inch Undercounter Bullet Ice Maker

Best for: Undercounter installation with a drain pump

Daily Ice Production

52 lbs/day

Storage Capacity

26 lbs

Ice Type

bullet

Form Factor

undercounter

Drain Type

built-in drain pump

Dimensions

23 × 15 × 35 inches

View on Amazon: COTLIN 15-Inch Undercounter Bullet Ice Maker Affiliate link

The COTLIN undercounter ice maker produces bullet ice using spray technology for slower melting. It holds 26 lbs of ice and includes a built-in drain pump for flexible installation. The unit measures 15 inches wide and features a front-facing vent, allowing it to sit flush under countertops. An LCD panel lets you adjust ice thickness and set a timer.

Pros

• Built-in drain pump for upward water removal
• Front-facing ventilation for flush installation
• Adjustable ice thickness and 12-hour timer
• Reversible door for left or right hinge

Cons

• 26 lb storage capacity is smaller than many competitors
• Bullet ice type rather than gourmet cubes
• No remote control included

Good fit if

• You need a drain pump for installation under a counter
• You want bullet ice that melts slowly in drinks
• You require a 15-inch wide unit for tight spaces

Skip if

• You prefer clear, solid gourmet cubes over bullet ice
• You need more than 26 lbs of ice storage
• You want a unit with a remote control

Verdict: COTLIN Undercounter Ice Maker with Pump fits users who need a 15-inch unit with a drain pump for undercounter installation. It is a solid choice for those who prefer bullet ice and have limited space for side ventilation.

4 Best clear ice

EdgeStar 15-Inch Undercounter Clear Ice Maker

Best for: clear ice in tight built-in spaces

Daily Ice Production

Up to 50 lbs./day

Storage Capacity

25 lbs

Ice Type

Clear, cubed ice

Form Factor

Undercounter, freestanding or built-in

Drain Type

Internal drain pump

Color

Stainless Steel

View on Amazon: EdgeStar 15-Inch Undercounter Clear Ice Maker Affiliate link

This EdgeStar unit produces up to 50 lbs of clear, cubed ice daily with a 25 lb storage bin. It includes an internal drain pump, allowing for flexible placement near a water source. The stainless steel door and reversible design support built-in or freestanding use. You get restaurant-quality ice in sheet form that requires breaking apart.

Pros

• Produces up to 50 lbs of clear ice per day
• Includes an internal drain pump for flexible installation
• Reversible door allows for built-in or freestanding setups

Cons

• Ice is produced in sheets, requiring manual breaking
• 25 lb storage capacity is limited for high-volume use
• Must be installed within 4.5 ft of a drain

Good fit if

• You want clear, cubed ice for cocktails
• You need a drain pump for built-in installation
• You have a 15-inch wide space available

Skip if

• You need individual cubes without manual breaking
• You require more than 25 lbs of storage
• Your drain is located more than 4.5 ft away

Verdict: EdgeStar IB450SSP 15-Inch Clear Ice Maker suits you if you prioritize clear ice quality and built-in flexibility over convenience, provided your plumbing is close enough.

5 Best budget

EUHOMY 110 lb Undercounter Ice Maker with Drain Pump

Best for: High-volume bars needing drain pump flexibility

Daily Ice Production

110 lbs/24h

Storage Capacity

33 lbs

Ice Type

Hat cube

Form Factor

Under counter, freestanding

Batch Time

10-15 minutes

Drain Type

Drain pump

View on Amazon: EUHOMY 110 lb Undercounter Ice Maker with Drain Pump Affiliate link

This EUHOMy unit produces 110 lbs of clear hat cubes daily, with a 33 lb storage bin. It includes an external drain pump for flexible installation where gravity drainage is not possible. The 16.9-inch width fits standard undercounter spaces. An LCD panel controls ice size and self-cleaning. It suits busy bars and cafes needing high-volume ice.

Pros

• Produces 110 lbs of ice per 24 hours
• Includes external drain pump for flexible placement
• 33 lb internal storage capacity for peak hours
• LCD panel with self-cleaning function

Cons

• 16.9-inch width exceeds standard 15-inch undercounter slots
• Produces hat cubes, not gourmet or nugget ice
• Requires 24-hour upright settling before first use

Good fit if

• You need high daily ice production for a bar
• You lack a floor drain and need a pump
• You have a 17-inch wide undercounter space

Skip if

• You require strict 15-inch width compliance
• You prefer nugget or crescent ice shapes
• You want a freestanding unit without plumbing

Verdict: EUHOMY 110 lb Undercounter Ice Maker delivers high volume for commercial settings but requires extra width and accepts hat cubes rather than gourmet shapes.

6 Best premium

Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker

Best for: bars and compact kitchens needing precise cubes

Daily Ice Production

65 lb/Day

Storage Capacity

26 lb

Ice Type

Gourmet Cube

Form Factor

Undercounter

Drain Type

Pump Drain

Features

Storage Bin, Drain Pump

View on Amazon: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Gourmet Ice Maker Affiliate link

This Scotsman undercounter ice maker produces 65 pounds of gourmet cubes daily with 26 pounds of storage. Its 15-inch width fits standard cabinetry, and the integrated pump drain allows placement away from gravity drains. The reversible door supports flexible installation in tight spaces. You get consistent 1-inch cubes ideal for portion control at bars or in compact prep areas where space is limited.

Pros

• Produces 65 pounds of gourmet cubes per day
• Includes built-in pump drain for flexible placement
• 15-inch width fits standard undercounter openings
• Field-reversible door for left or right swing
• 26 pounds of ice storage capacity

Cons

• 26-pound storage bin is smaller than some competitors
• No mention of digital display or app control
• Heavier build at 105 pounds

Good fit if

• You need consistent 1-inch cubes for bar service
• You require a pump drain for remote installation
• You have a 15-inch undercounter space

Skip if

• You need nugget or crushed ice
• You require a large storage bin over 26 pounds
• You want smart connectivity features

Verdict: Scotsman Undercounter Gourmet Cube 65 lb delivers precise portioning for bars and compact kitchens. It suits users who prioritize cube quality and flexible drain placement over high-volume storage.

7 Best 100 lbs/day

EUHOMY 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker

Best for: High-volume ice needs with pump drainage

Daily Ice Production

100 lbs

Storage Capacity

24 lbs

Ice Type

cube

Form Factor

undercounter, built-in, freestanding

Batch Time

10–18 minutes

Drain Type

electric drain pump

View on Amazon: EUHOMY 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link

This undercounter ice maker produces up to 100 pounds of ice per day. It includes a built-in drain pump for flexible installation without a floor drain. The 24-pound storage bin holds enough ice for busy households or small commercial spaces. You can adjust ice thickness and set a 24-hour timer via the LCD panel. It fits standard 15-inch wide cabinets.

Pros

• Produces 100 lbs of ice daily
• Includes electric drain pump
• 24 lb storage bin capacity
• Adjustable ice thickness settings

Cons

• Height is 33.6 inches, limiting under-cabinet fit
• Requires 24 hours upright before first use
• No remote control included

Good fit if

• You need high daily ice output
• You lack a floor drain
• You want adjustable ice thickness

Skip if

• You need a compact 15-inch height
• You prefer gravity drainage only
• You want remote operation

Verdict: EUHOMy 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker suits users who need high volume and flexible drainage but can accommodate its taller 33.6-inch profile.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• sm sunnimix heavy duty stepping machine handles alternatives
• primochill ice alternatives