Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The scotsman uc2024ma 1 24 air cooled cube undercounter ice maker delivers high-volume production for tight spaces. It generates up to 227 pounds of ice daily while storing 80 pounds in a narrow 24-inch footprint. This model suits users who need speed and capacity without sacrificing floor space. The front-breathing design allows placement against walls without side clearance. However, you might prefer a different option for specific reasons. Some buyers need a narrower 15-inch or 18-inch width to fit tighter cabinets. Others may require ADA-compliant heights for accessible service areas. You might also want a different ice type, such as crescent or cubelet shapes, for particular drink preferences. The alternatives listed here were chosen because their specifications overlap with the original Scotsman model. Each pick shares key traits like undercounter form factors and air-cooled systems. This comparison helps you find a machine that matches your exact spatial and output requirements. We focus strictly on published specs to guide your decision. You can review the detailed breakdowns below to see how each unit compares.
Our top pick: Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker.
How Each Alternative Compares
Hoshizaki 18-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker
The Hoshizaki 18-Inch model narrows the width to 17.8 inches, offering a tighter fit for spaces where the 24-inch Scotsman is too wide. It maintains the same 39-inch height and undercounter form factor, ensuring it slides into similar cabinetry. You gain a more compact footprint without sacrificing the air-cooled efficiency found in the original. However, this model produces crescent ice rather than the cube style of the Scotsman. If your kitchen has strict width constraints but you still need high-volume output, this narrower frame is a practical swap. The stainless steel build matches the premium feel of the Scotsman while saving valuable counter space.
Hoshizaki 15-Inch Undercounter Cubelet Ice Maker
This Hoshizaki 15-Inch Cubelet Ice Maker significantly reduces the width to just 15 inches, making it ideal for very tight installations. It produces 80 pounds of ice daily, which is substantially less than the 227-pound capacity of the Scotsman original. You trade raw volume for extreme space efficiency. The unit is shorter at 33.5 inches and narrower at 22.5 inches in depth. It uses air cooling and stainless steel construction, aligning with the durability of the Scotsman. This pick suits users who need reliable ice production in small areas or outdoor setups where the larger Scotsman cannot fit. It is a best premium choice for compact, steady output.
Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker
The Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker offers a 100-pound daily production rate, which is lower than the 227-pound output of the original. It features a 20-inch width, making it narrower than the 24-inch Scotsman but still wider than some competitors. The black color provides a different aesthetic compared to the stainless steel original. It stands 38 inches tall, slightly shorter than the 39-inch original. This model is designed for tight spaces where side clearance is unavailable. It suits users who prioritize a black finish or need a slightly smaller footprint. The air-cooled system ensures efficient operation, though you get less ice per day.
Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker
The Hoshizaki 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker matches the 24-inch width of the Scotsman original but produces crescent ice instead of cubes. It is 28.3 inches deep, which is deeper than the 24-inch depth of the Scotsman. The height is the same at 39 inches. This model delivers serious volume for busy bars and ADA-compliant setups. You gain a similar width but a different ice shape and greater depth. It requires separate plumbing, which differs from the self-contained nature of the Scotsman. The stainless steel finish matches the original. This pick is for users who need high-volume crescent ice and have the space for a deeper unit.
Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker
The Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker is significantly narrower at 15 inches wide, fitting into tighter spaces than the 24-inch Scotsman. It is also shorter at 31.5 inches, making it suitable for ADA-compliant counters. The unit produces cube ice, similar to the Scotsman, but in a smaller footprint. It weighs 121 pounds, which is lighter than the 150-pound Scotsman. The air-cooled system ensures efficient operation in compact areas. This model is ideal for commercial spaces requiring ADA compliance and narrow width. You trade the higher production volume of the Scotsman for a more accessible and space-efficient design. The stainless steel build offers durability comparable to the original.
Scotsman 15" Undercounter Ice Maker
The Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker offers a narrower 14.9-inch width, making it a better fit for tight spaces than the 24-inch original. It produces extra-large cubes, which may differ from the standard cube size of the original. The unit is shorter at 34.4 inches and narrower in depth at 22.8 inches. It uses an air-cooled system, maintaining the efficiency of the Scotsman brand. This model suits users who need reliable ice production but cannot accommodate the larger 24-inch footprint. You gain flexibility in door orientation and space savings. The trade-off is a smaller overall capacity and different ice cube size. It is a practical choice for compact kitchens.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker
Best for: High-volume ice needs in tight spaces
- Daily Ice Production
- 227 lbs/Day
- Storage Capacity
- 80 lb.
- Ice Type
- Cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Scotsman UC2024MA-1 is a 24-inch air-cooled undercounter ice maker that produces up to 227 pounds of cube ice daily. It stores 80 pounds of ice in its bin. The unit features a stainless steel finish and front-breathing design, meaning it requires no side clearance. This model is built for high output in tight spaces, making it suitable for busy kitchens or commercial settings where speed and capacity matter.
Pros
- Produces up to 227 lbs of cube ice per day
- Stores 80 lbs of ice for quick access
- Front-breathing design requires no side clearance
- Includes removable external air filter for easy cleaning
- Comes with a 3-year parts and labor warranty
Cons
- 28.5-inch width exceeds standard 24-inch cabinet openings
- 150-pound weight requires sturdy counter support
- Air-cooled system may generate more ambient heat than water-cooled units
Good fit if
- You need high-volume ice production for a busy household
- You have a tight space where side clearance is not possible
- You want a durable unit with a long warranty
Skip if
- You require a water-cooled system for lower ambient heat
- You have a standard 24-inch cabinet opening without modification
- You need a lighter unit for easy relocation
Verdict: Scotsman 24-Inch Cube Ice Maker delivers exceptional daily output for high-demand environments. It fits users who prioritize speed and capacity over a compact footprint.
Hoshizaki 18-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker
Best for: tight spaces needing high volume
- Daily Ice Production
- 86 lbs/Day
- Storage Capacity
- 38 lb.
- Ice Type
- Crescent Cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 18-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker Affiliate link
The Hoshizaki KM-81BAJ is a 17.75-inch air-cooled undercounter ice maker. It produces up to 86 pounds of crescent cube ice daily. You get 38 pounds of storage in the front-opening bin. The unit is ADA compliant and ENERGY STAR certified. This model suits commercial kitchens or busy home bars where space is tight but ice volume matters.
Pros
- Produces up to 86 lbs of ice per day
- Includes 38 lbs of internal storage capacity
- ADA compliant height for accessible operation
- ENERGY STAR certified for efficiency
Cons
- Narrower 17.75-inch width limits placement options
- Lower storage capacity than larger 24-inch models
- Requires specific 115v electrical connection
Good fit if
- You need a narrower unit for tight spaces
- You require ADA compliant counter height
- You want high daily production in a compact footprint
Skip if
- You need a 24-inch wide unit
- You require water-cooled condenser efficiency
- You need more than 38 lbs of storage
Verdict: Hoshizaki KM-81BAJ 17.75-Inch Undercounter Ice Maker delivers high output in a narrow frame. It fits kitchens where width is restricted but volume is not.
Hoshizaki 15-Inch Undercounter Cubelet Ice Maker
Best for: tight spaces and outdoor use
- Daily Ice Production
- up to 80 lb/24 hours
- Storage Capacity
- 22 lb.
- Ice Type
- cubelet style
- Form Factor
- undercounter
- Daily Capacity
- 80 lbs/Day
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 15-Inch Undercounter Cubelet Ice Maker Affiliate link
This Hoshizaki undercounter unit produces cubelet ice with a daily capacity of 80 pounds. It features a 22-pound storage bin and measures 15 inches wide. The stainless steel exterior is approved for outdoor use. You should choose this if you need compact ice production for small bars or kitchens. It fits well in tight spaces where larger machines will not.
Pros
- Produces 80 pounds of ice per 24 hours
- 15-inch width fits tight undercounter spaces
- Approved for outdoor use
- 22-pound built-in storage capacity
Cons
- Smaller 22-pound storage bin compared to larger models
- Produces cubelet ice rather than standard cubes
- Air-cooled system requires adequate ventilation
Good fit if
- You need a narrow unit for tight spaces
- You require ice production for small commercial or residential use
- You want a unit approved for outdoor installation
Skip if
- You need high-volume production over 80 pounds daily
- You prefer standard cube ice over cubelets
- You have limited clearance for 33.5-inch height
Verdict: Hoshizaki 15-Inch Cubelet Ice Maker offers reliable 80-pound daily production in a narrow 15-inch footprint. It suits buyers who need compact, outdoor-approved ice making for small-scale operations.
Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: tight spaces with no side clearance
- Daily Ice Production
- Up to 100 lbs
- Storage Capacity
- 57 lbs
- Ice Type
- Cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
This 20-inch wide air-cooled undercounter ice maker produces up to 100 pounds of cube ice daily with a 57-pound storage bin. Its front-breathing design eliminates the need for side clearance, allowing flexible placement in tight spaces. The unit is ADA compliant and features a horizontal evaporator for clear cubes. It includes a slide-back door and adjustable legs for easy access and installation.
Pros
- Produces up to 100 lbs of ice per day
- 20-inch width fits tight spaces with no side clearance needed
- Stores 57 lbs of ice in the bin
- ADA compliant height and design
- Includes ice scoop and adjustable legs
Cons
- 57 lb storage is smaller than the 100 lb daily production rate
- 115 lb weight makes it difficult to move
- Black finish shows fingerprints easily
Good fit if
- You need an ice maker that fits in a 20-inch wide opening
- You require ADA compliant height for accessibility
- You want front-breathing cooling for flexible placement
Skip if
- You need more than 57 lbs of ice storage capacity
- You prefer a white or stainless steel finish
- You require a model with a digital display
Verdict: Scotsman CU0920MA-1 20-Inch Cube Ice Maker fits users who need high daily production in a narrow footprint. It suits tight kitchens where side clearance is unavailable and ADA height is required.
Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker
Best for: High-volume ADA-compliant setups
- Daily Ice Production
- up to 163 lb/24 hours
- Storage Capacity
- 78 lb
- Ice Type
- crescent
- Form Factor
- undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker Affiliate link
This Hoshizaki unit produces up to 163 pounds of crescent ice daily. It holds 78 pounds in its built-in bin. The stainless steel exterior fits under counters at 23.8 inches wide. It meets ADA compliance standards. You get a self-contained condenser for air cooling. This machine suits high-volume needs where crescent ice is preferred.
Pros
- Produces up to 163 lb of ice per 24 hours
- 78 lb built-in storage capacity
- ADA compliant design
- NSF and UL certified
Cons
- Crescent ice style, not cube
- No water line included
- Requires 6-inch legs for clearance
Good fit if
- You need high daily production
- You prefer crescent ice
- You require ADA compliance
Skip if
- You need cube ice
- You want a compact 15-inch width
- You need a built-in water connection
Verdict: Hoshizaki KM-161BAJ 24-Inch Crescent Ice Maker delivers serious volume for busy bars. It fits ADA spaces but requires separate plumbing.
Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: ADA compliant narrow undercounter ice needs
- Daily Ice Production
- 55 lbs/Day
- Storage Capacity
- 22 lb.
- Ice Type
- Top Hat style full cube
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
- Color
- Stainless Steel
View on Amazon: Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
This Hoshizaki unit produces 55 pounds of top hat cubes daily. It fits undercounter spaces with a 15-inch width. The 22-pound storage bin holds ice for service. It meets ADA height requirements at 31.5 inches. You get stainless steel construction and NSF certification. This model suits commercial kitchens needing reliable, compliant ice production.
Pros
- Produces 55 lbs of ice per day
- ADA compliant height for accessible use
- NSF and UL certified for safety
- 22 lb storage capacity included
Cons
- Narrow 15-inch width limits placement
- Heavy 121-pound build requires strong flooring
- Lower daily production than 24-inch competitors
Good fit if
- You need ADA compliant counter height
- You have a narrow 15-inch undercounter space
- You require NSF certified commercial equipment
Skip if
- You need more than 55 lbs of daily production
- You require a wider 24-inch footprint
- You prefer a lighter unit for easier moving
Verdict: Hoshizaki ADA 15-Inch Cube Ice Maker fits tight commercial spaces requiring ADA compliance. It delivers steady cube production for busy service environments.
Scotsman 15" Undercounter Ice Maker
Best for: tight spaces needing extra-large cubes
- Daily Ice Production
- 30 lbs/Day
- Storage Capacity
- 26 lb
- Ice Type
- Extra-large cubes
- Form Factor
- Undercounter
- Drain Type
- Gravity drain
- Cooling Type
- Air-Cooled
View on Amazon: Scotsman 15" Undercounter Ice Maker Affiliate link
This Scotsman unit is a 15-inch undercounter ice maker designed for steady daily production. It generates 30 pounds of extra-large cubes each day and stores up to 26 pounds in its internal bin. The air-cooled condenser uses R290 refrigerant for efficient operation. You will appreciate the field-reversible door, which allows for left- or right-hand installation. It features a gravity drain for passive water removal and automatic shutoff based on bin fill levels.
Pros
- Produces 30 lbs of ice daily
- 26 lb storage bin capacity
- Air-cooled condenser with R290 refrigerant
- Field-reversible door for flexible installation
Cons
- Narrower 15-inch width limits countertop space savings compared to 24-inch models
- Taller 34.4-inch height may not fit all undercounter spaces
- No automatic water line connection mentioned; relies on gravity drain
Good fit if
- You need a compact 15-inch footprint for tight spaces
- You prefer extra-large cube ice for beverages
- You require a field-reversible door for specific cabinetry layouts
Skip if
- You need a wider 24-inch unit for higher production
- You require an automatic water line hookup without manual filling
- You need a shorter unit that fits under standard 34-inch counters
Verdict: Scotsman 15-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker offers reliable daily production in a narrower footprint. It fits users who need extra-large cubes and flexible door orientation but cannot accommodate wider 24-inch machines.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker | Hoshizaki 18-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker | Hoshizaki 15-Inch Undercounter Cubelet Ice Maker | Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker | Hoshizaki 24-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker | Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker | Scotsman 15" Undercounter Ice Maker |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Daily Ice Production | 227 lbs/Day | 86 lbs/Day | up to 80 lb/24 hours | Up to 100 lbs | up to 163 lb/24 hours | 55 lbs/Day | 30 lbs/Day |
| Storage Capacity | 80 lb. | 38 lb. | 22 lb. | 57 lbs | 78 lb | 22 lb. | 26 lb |
| Ice Type | Cube | Crescent Cube | cubelet style | Cube | crescent | Top Hat style full cube | Extra-large cubes |
| Form Factor | Undercounter | Undercounter | undercounter | Undercounter | undercounter | Undercounter | Undercounter |
| Drain Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Gravity drain |
| Daily Capacity | not stated | not stated | 80 lbs/Day | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Cooling Type | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled | Air-Cooled |
| Color | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Black | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | not stated |
| Dimensions | 24 × 28.5 × 39 inches | 24 × 17.8 × 39 inches | 22.5 × 15 × 33.5 inches | 20 × 24 × 38 inches | 28.3 × 23.8 × 39 inches | 22.5 × 15 × 31.5 inches | 22.8 × 14.9 × 34.4 inches |
| Weight | 150 pounds | not stated | not stated | 115 pounds | not stated | 121 pounds | not stated |
| Model | UC2024MA-1 | 1145-00370 | C-80BAJ | CU0920MA-1 | 1145-00495 | AM-50BAJ-AD | not stated |
| Size | not stated | not stated | not stated | 100 lb / day | not stated | not stated | not stated |
For PC thermal management projects, you can compare barrow memory air cooled alternatives by mounting dimensions and airflow clearance.
Frequently asked questions
Which undercounter ice maker has the smallest width?
The Hoshizaki 15-Inch Undercounter Cubelet Ice Maker and the Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker both share the narrowest footprint. They measure 15 inches in width. This dimension allows them to fit into tighter cabinetry spaces than the 24-inch Scotsman model. You should choose these if your available width is restricted.
Do these ice makers require water connection?
The provided data lists cooling type as air-cooled for all models. This means they use air to cool the refrigeration system rather than water. While ice makers typically need water for production, the specs do not mention a water line requirement. You should verify plumbing needs with the manufacturer before installation.
Which model is best for ADA compliance?
The Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker is explicitly labeled for ADA compliance. It stands 31.5 inches tall, which helps meet accessibility height requirements. The Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker is also noted as suitable for ADA height needs. Check the exact height against your counter clearance.
How tall are these undercounter ice makers?
Most models stand between 31.5 and 39 inches tall. The Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker and the Hoshizaki 18-Inch Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker both reach 39 inches. The Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA model is shorter at 31.5 inches. Ensure your cabinet height accommodates the specific unit you select.
Can I find these ice makers in black?
Yes, the Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker is available in black. All other listed models feature a stainless steel finish. If you prefer a black exterior to match other appliances, this specific Scotsman model is your only option among the picks shown.
Which ice maker is the heaviest?
The Scotsman 24-Inch Undercounter Cube Ice Maker is the heaviest at 150 pounds. The Hoshizaki 15-Inch ADA Undercounter Ice Maker follows at 121 pounds. The Scotsman 100 lb Black Undercounter Ice Maker weighs 115 pounds. Heavier units may require more support during installation and moving.
What ice shape do these machines produce?
The Scotsman 24-Inch model produces cube ice. The Hoshizaki 18-Inch and 24-Inch models make crescent ice. The Hoshizaki 15-Inch Cubelet model produces cubelet ice. The Scotsman 15-Inch model also makes extra-large cubes. Choose based on whether you prefer standard cubes, crescents, or cubelets for your drinks.
Are these units suitable for outdoor use?
The Hoshizaki 15-Inch Undercounter Cubelet Ice Maker is noted as suitable for outdoor use. Most other models are designed for standard indoor undercounter installation. If you plan to place a unit outdoors, verify the specific model's environmental rating. The Cubelet model is the clear choice for that scenario.