Summit Appliance 24" Freezer Ice Maker Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking for summit appliance 24 freezer ice maker alternatives to replace the Summit SCFF53BSSIM. This unit measures 23.6 inches wide, 34 inches high, and 23.5 inches deep. It offers a compact, integrated solution for users who prioritize ice making and cabinetry fit over raw storage capacity. The black finish and freezer-only design suit specific kitchen layouts.
You might want something else if you need more internal space or a different form factor. The alternatives were chosen because their specs overlap with the original in terms of footprint or application. Some picks offer chest designs for garage use. Others provide upright models with locks for secure dorm storage. You can compare the width, height, and cubic footage to find a better fit for your room. Each option targets a specific need, from quiet operation to high-capacity bulk storage. This list helps you evaluate the trade-offs between the original compact size and other available volumes.
Our top pick: Summit 24" Stainless Steel Freezer.
How each alternative compares
Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Single Door Mini Fridge
The Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Mini Fridge is significantly smaller than the Summit model. It measures 19.2 inches wide, 17.1 inches high, and 18.7 inches deep, compared to the Summit’s 23.6 by 34 by 23.5 inches. This compact footprint makes it suitable for tight spaces where the Summit would not fit. However, you sacrifice the larger capacity and integrated freezer design of the Summit. The Frostorm is best for users who need a quiet, small unit for ice storage rather than a full freezer. It lacks the height and width of the Summit, offering less overall volume but greater flexibility in placement.
Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
The Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer differs in form factor and capacity. It is a chest-style unit measuring 21.3 inches wide, 33.1 inches high, and 25 inches deep. While slightly narrower than the Summit’s 23.6 inches, it is deeper and offers a different storage layout. The Igloo provides 5.0 cubic feet of space, which is less than the Summit’s implied larger capacity but more than the smaller uprights. It includes an adjustable thermostat and interior LED light, features not listed for the Summit. This model is ideal for garages or basements where upright space is limited. You trade the Summit’s upright convenience for chest-style access and manual controls.
BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer
The BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer offers substantial capacity in a chest design. It measures 17.3 inches wide, 33.5 inches high, and 21.6 inches deep. This unit is narrower than the Summit’s 23.6 inches but provides 7.0 cubic feet of storage. The BODACIOUS includes an adjustable thermostat and is designed for apartments and garages. It is heavier at 48.5 pounds compared to the Summit’s unspecified weight. This model is best for users who need high volume and quiet operation. You give up the Summit’s upright orientation and integrated ice maker focus in exchange for larger, chest-style storage and a narrower footprint that may fit tighter spaces.
Whynter 1.1 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer with Lock
The Whynter 1.1 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer is much smaller than the Summit. It measures 17.7 inches wide, 19.5 inches high, and 18 inches deep. This compact size makes it suitable for dorms or offices where the Summit would be too large. The Whynter includes a lock, a feature not mentioned for the Summit. It offers 1.1 cubic feet of storage, significantly less than the Summit’s capacity. This model is ideal for users who prioritize secure, compact storage. You sacrifice the Summit’s larger volume and integrated design for a smaller, lockable unit that fits in tight spaces. The Whynter is best for those needing minimal freezing capacity with added security.
Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
The Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer provides high volume in a chest design. It measures 32.2 inches wide, 33.7 inches high, and 22 inches deep. This unit is wider than the Summit’s 23.6 inches but offers 7.0 cubic feet of storage. The Kismile is designed for home use and prioritizes bulk storage and quiet operation. It is heavier at 60.5 pounds compared to the Summit’s unspecified weight. This model is best for households needing large capacity. You trade the Summit’s upright orientation and integrated ice maker for chest-style access and greater volume. The Kismile is ideal for users who value storage space over the compact, upright design of the Summit.
Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
The Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer offers substantial capacity in a chest design. It measures 37 inches wide, 33 inches high, and 26 inches deep. This unit is significantly wider than the Summit’s 23.6 inches but provides 7 cubic feet of storage. The Frigidaire includes an adjustable thermostat, a feature not listed for the Summit. It is the heaviest option at 70 pounds. This model is ideal for users who prioritize capacity and durability. You give up the Summit’s upright orientation and integrated ice maker focus for chest-style access and manual controls. The Frigidaire is best for those needing large, reliable storage in a garage or basement setting.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Summit 24" Stainless Steel Freezer
Best for: compact kitchen ice making
- Form Factor
- Built-in, Undercounter
- Temperature Control
- Digital thermostat
- Features
- Freezer
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 23.5 × 23.6 × 34 inches
View on Amazon: Summit 24" Stainless Steel Freezer Affiliate link
This Summit Appliance unit is a 24-inch wide upright freezer designed for built-in or standalone use. It measures 34 inches high and 23.5 inches deep, fitting standard kitchen cabinetry. The exterior features a stainless steel finish, while the interior is black. It includes a dedicated ice maker for automatic ice production. This model suits users needing a compact, integrated cooling solution with ice capabilities.
Pros
- 24-inch width fits standard cabinetry
- Includes an automatic ice maker
- Stainless steel exterior finish
- Upright design for easy access
Cons
- Black interior limits visibility of contents
- No mention of adjustable shelves or bins
- Limited capacity compared to chest freezers
Good fit if
- You need a built-in style freezer
- You want automatic ice production
- You have limited kitchen space
Skip if
- You require maximum storage volume
- You prefer a chest freezer design
- You need a portable unit
Verdict: Summit 24" Stainless Steel Freezer offers a compact, integrated solution for users who prioritize ice making and cabinetry fit over raw storage capacity. It is ideal for kitchens where space is at a premium.
Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Single Door Mini Fridge
Best for: small spaces and quiet ice storage
- Total Capacity
- 1.6 Cu Ft
- Form Factor
- Upright
- Temperature Control
- 1-5 mechanical thermostat
- Door Configuration
- Single reversible door
- Interior Organization
- Metal shelf
- Features
- Freezer, Reversible Door, Adjustable Thermostat
View on Amazon: Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Single Door Mini Fridge Affiliate link
The Frostorm is a 1.6 Cu Ft upright unit with a dedicated 0.2 Cu Ft freezer compartment. It reaches -14°C to -24°C for ice storage. The 30dB operation keeps noise low for bedrooms or offices. You get a reversible single door and a mechanical thermostat. Its compact 19.2-inch width fits small spaces. This model suits those needing basic frozen storage without complex controls.
Pros
- Dedicated 0.2 Cu Ft freezer reaches -14°C to -24°C
- Ultra-quiet 30dB operation suitable for bedrooms or offices
- Reversible single door adapts to left or right opening
- Compact 19.2-inch width fits tight spaces
Cons
- Small 1.6 Cu Ft total capacity limits storage
- Basic mechanical thermostat lacks precise digital control
- No automatic defrost feature included
Good fit if
- You need a quiet unit for a bedroom or dorm
- You require a reversible door for tight layouts
- You want a compact freezer for ice and snacks
Skip if
- You need large capacity for bulk food storage
- You prefer digital temperature controls over mechanical dials
- You require an automatic defrost system
Verdict: Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Upright Mini Fridge fits users needing quiet, compact ice storage in small rooms. It offers essential freezing in a space-saving footprint.
Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
Best for: garage or basement cold storage
- Total Capacity
- 5.0 cu. ft.
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Temperature Control
- Adjustable thermostat dial
- Door Configuration
- Balanced hinge (holds open 45° to 90°)
- Interior Organization
- Removable wire organizer basket
- Features
- Freezer, Interior LED Light, Adjustable Thermostat
View on Amazon: Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link
This Igloo chest freezer offers 5.0 cubic feet of storage in a compact black design. It features a quick freezing system with a D-type refrigeration tube and an adjustable thermostat dial for precise temperature control. The balanced hinge holds the lid open between 45 and 90 degrees. Front rollers aid mobility, while a removable wire basket organizes contents. It suits those needing reliable garage or basement storage.
Pros
- 5.0 cu. ft. total capacity
- Quick freezing D-type refrigeration tube
- Balanced hinge holds lid open
- Front rollers for easy mobility
- Adjustable thermostat dial
Cons
- Chest style requires bending to access items
- No digital display or electronic controls
- Limited to 5.0 cu. ft. capacity
Good fit if
- You need extra storage for a garage or basement
- You prefer manual dial temperature control
- You want a unit with front rollers for movement
Skip if
- You require upright door access for small spaces
- You need digital temperature readouts
- You want a capacity larger than 5.0 cu. ft.
Verdict: Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Black Chest Freezer provides solid cold storage for garages or basements. It fits buyers who value manual control and easy mobility over upright convenience.
BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer
Best for: apartments needing quiet, high-capacity storage
- Total Capacity
- 7.0 cu. ft.
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Temperature Control
- 6-setting adjustable thermostat
- Door Configuration
- Top open door
- Interior Organization
- Removable basket
- Features
- Freezer
View on Amazon: BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer Affiliate link
This BODACIOUS chest freezer offers 7.0 cubic feet of storage in a compact footprint measuring 17.3 by 21.6 inches. It features a 6-setting adjustable thermostat and operates quietly, making it suitable for apartments or garages. The unit includes a removable basket for organization and an exterior defrost drain for easy maintenance. Its energy-efficient design helps keep running costs low while preserving frozen goods.
Pros
- 7.0 cubic feet total capacity
- 6-setting adjustable thermostat
- Quiet operation for indoor use
- Removable interior basket
- Exterior defrost water drain
Cons
- Top-opening door limits easy access
- No digital display or lock
- Manual defrost required
Good fit if
- You need high capacity in a small footprint
- You want quiet operation for an apartment
- You prefer manual temperature control
Skip if
- You need a top-mount freezer door
- You require digital temperature displays
- You want a lockable unit
Verdict: BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer fits apartments and garages where space is tight but storage volume matters. Its quiet motor and adjustable thermostat make it a practical choice for storing meats and ice cream without noise disruption.
Whynter 1.1 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer with Lock
Best for: secure storage in small spaces
- Total Capacity
- 1.1 Cu Ft
- Form Factor
- Upright
- Temperature Control
- mechanical temperature control
- Interior Organization
- removable slide-out wire freezer shelf
- Features
- Freezer, Lock
- Application
- Dorm, Garage
View on Amazon: Whynter 1.1 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer with Lock Affiliate link
This Whynter upright freezer offers 1.1 cubic feet of cold storage in a compact 17.7-inch width. It features a mechanical thermostat adjustable from -11°F to 10.4°F and includes a cylinder lock with two keys for secure storage. The interior has a removable wire shelf. It suits dorms, offices, or garages where space is tight and security matters.
Pros
- Includes a cylinder lock and two keys for security
- Mechanical temperature control ranges from -11°F to 10.4°F
- Compact 17.7-inch width fits small spaces
- Removable slide-out wire shelf for flexible storage
Cons
- 1.1 cubic feet capacity is smaller than full-size alternatives
- Mechanical controls lack digital precision
- No internal light or digital display
Good fit if
- You need a locked freezer for a dorm or office
- You have limited floor space under 18 inches wide
- You want a simple mechanical temperature control
Skip if
- You need more than 1.1 cubic feet of storage
- You prefer digital temperature displays
- You require a stainless steel finish
Verdict: Whynter 1.1 Cu Ft Upright Freezer with Lock fits users who need secure, compact storage in tight spaces like dorms or offices. It is ideal if you prioritize physical security over digital features.
Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
Best for: bulk storage and quiet indoor use
- Total Capacity
- 7.0 Cu.ft
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Temperature Control
- 7-grade adjustable thermostat
- Door Configuration
- Top open door, stays open 45° to 90°
- Interior Organization
- 3 hanging wire storage baskets
- Features
- Freezer
View on Amazon: Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link
The Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer offers substantial storage in a black, horizontal design. It features a 7-grade adjustable thermostat ranging from 6.8°F to -7.6°F. The unit includes three hanging wire baskets for organized storage. It operates quietly below 38 dB and consumes 0.66 kWh daily. This model suits users needing deep freeze capacity for bulk items, meat, or breast milk.
Pros
- 7.0 cubic feet total capacity
- 7-grade adjustable thermostat control
- Includes three hanging wire baskets
- Low noise operation below 38 dB
Cons
- Chest style requires bending to access items
- No digital temperature display
- Fixed black finish only
Good fit if
- You need large capacity for bulk food storage
- You want a quiet unit for indoor use
- You prefer mechanical temperature controls
Skip if
- You need upright vertical storage
- You require digital temperature readouts
- You want a white finish
Verdict: Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer fits households prioritizing high volume and quiet operation over upright convenience.
Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer
Best for: Bulk frozen food storage
- Total Capacity
- 7.0 cu. ft.
- Form Factor
- Chest
- Temperature Control
- Adjustable thermostat knob (7 settings)
- Door Configuration
- Top door
- Interior Organization
- Removable vinyl-coated wire basket
- Features
- Freezer, Adjustable Thermostat
View on Amazon: Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer Affiliate link
This Frigidaire chest freezer offers 7.0 cu. ft. of storage for frozen goods. It features an adjustable thermostat with seven settings for precise temperature control. The interior includes a removable vinyl-coated wire basket for organization. You get an aluminum interior liner for durability and a power-on indicator light. Its top-opening door design helps retain cold air. This unit suits those needing bulk storage space.
Pros
- 7.0 cu. ft. total capacity
- Adjustable thermostat with 7 settings
- Removable vinyl-coated wire basket
- Aluminum interior liner
Cons
- Top-opening door requires bending
- No digital display or controls
- Manual defrost only
Good fit if
- You need high-capacity frozen storage
- You prefer manual temperature adjustments
- You want a durable aluminum interior
Skip if
- You need upright door access
- You require digital temperature controls
- You want automatic defrosting
Verdict: Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer provides substantial storage and reliable manual control. It fits users who prioritize capacity and durability over upright convenience.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Summit 24" Stainless Steel Freezer | Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Single Door Mini Fridge | Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer | BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer | Whynter 1.1 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer with Lock | Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer | Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Capacity | not stated | 1.6 Cu Ft | 5.0 cu. ft. | 7.0 cu. ft. | 1.1 Cu Ft | 7.0 Cu.ft | 7.0 cu. ft. |
| Form Factor | Built-in, Undercounter | Upright | Chest | Chest | Upright | Chest | Chest |
| Temperature Control | Digital thermostat | 1-5 mechanical thermostat | Adjustable thermostat dial | 6-setting adjustable thermostat | mechanical temperature control | 7-grade adjustable thermostat | Adjustable thermostat knob (7 settings) |
| Door Configuration | not stated | Single reversible door | Balanced hinge (holds open 45° to 90°) | Top open door | not stated | Top open door, stays open 45° to 90° | Top door |
| Interior Organization | not stated | Metal shelf | Removable wire organizer basket | Removable basket | removable slide-out wire freezer shelf | 3 hanging wire storage baskets | Removable vinyl-coated wire basket |
| Features | Freezer | Freezer, Reversible Door, Adjustable Thermostat | Freezer, Interior LED Light, Adjustable Thermostat | Freezer | Freezer, Lock | Freezer | Freezer, Adjustable Thermostat |
| Application | not stated | Office, Dorm, Bedroom | Home, Garage | Home, Garage, Apartment | Dorm, Garage | Home, Office, Bar, Kitchen | not stated |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black |
| Room | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Home Bar | not stated |
| Placement | not stated | not stated | Basement | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 23.5 × 23.6 × 34 inches | 18.7 × 19.2 × 17.1 inches | 25 × 21.3 × 33.1 inches | 21.6 × 17.3 × 33.5 inches | 18 × 17.7 × 19.5 inches | 22 × 32.2 × 33.7 inches | 26 × 37 × 33 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 40.7 pounds | 53.8 pounds | 48.5 pounds | not stated | 60.5 pounds | 70 pounds |
| Model | SCFF53BSSIM | BC-50-1 | Igloo | BD-100Q-B | CUF-110B | D200H-B | EFRF7003-BLACK |
| Size | not stated | 1.6 Cu Ft | 5.0 Cu. Ft. | 7.0 Cubic Feet | 1.1 Cubic Feet | 7.0 Cu.ft | 7 cu ft |
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative is best for small spaces?
The Frostorm 1.6 Cu Ft Mini Fridge is the best choice for tight areas. It measures 19.2 inches wide, 17.1 inches high, and 18.7 inches deep. This compact footprint fits where the larger Summit model cannot. It also weighs only 40.7 pounds, making it easy to move if needed.
What is the largest capacity option available?
The BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer offers the highest storage volume in this list. It provides ample space for bulk ice and frozen goods. The Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. model is another high-capacity alternative. Both units prioritize volume over the compact dimensions of the Summit appliance.
Is there a model with a security lock?
Yes, the Whynter 1.1 Cu. Ft. Upright Freezer includes a lock. This feature is useful for dorms or offices where you need to secure your items. It is one of the few units in this group that provides physical security. The Summit model does not list this feature in its specifications.
Which freezer is suitable for garage use?
The Igloo 5.0 Cu. Ft. Chest Freezer is designed for garage or basement placement. It is built to handle those environments while providing cold storage. The BODACIOUS model is also listed for home, garage, and apartment use. These options are better suited for out-of-kitchen locations than the compact Summit unit.
How wide are the chest freezer alternatives?
Chest freezers generally require more width than the Summit 24-inch model. The Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. model is 32.2 inches wide. The Frigidaire 7 Cu. Ft. model is 37 inches wide. These units are wider than the Summit’s 23.6-inch width, so you must measure your floor space carefully before buying.
Which option is best for quiet indoor use?
The BODACIOUS 7.0 Cu Ft Chest Freezer is noted for its quiet motor. It is ideal for apartments or bedrooms where noise disruption is a concern. The Kismile 7.0 Cu. Ft. model is also recommended for quiet indoor use. These units offer high capacity without the noise issues of larger commercial units.