6 Best Alternatives to the Antarctic Star Countertop Crescent Ice Maker (2026)

How each alternative compares

SenCre 26.5 lb Countertop Ice Maker

The SenCre model produces bullet ice rather than crescent cubes. You get 26.5 lbs of ice daily, which is slightly less than the Antarctic Star’s 27 lbs. It makes ice in roughly the same timeframe. The unit is smaller at 11.9 inches wide and 12.1 inches tall. It weighs 15 pounds, making it lighter and easier to move. You lose the slow-melting crystal quality of crescent ice. This option suits you if you prefer the chewable texture of bullet ice for sodas or quick chilling. It includes a self-cleaning function, similar to the Antarctic Star. The silver finish differs from the glossy black original. Choose this if compact size and bullet ice texture matter more than drink dilution control.

COWSAR 27 lb Crescent Countertop Ice Maker

The COWSAR unit closely mirrors the Antarctic Star in dimensions and ice type. It measures 14.1 inches wide, 15.8 inches tall, and 9.45 inches deep. It also produces 27 lbs of ice daily. The key difference is the ice classification. COWSAR markets its output as clear ice, while Antarctic Star specifies crescent ice. Both shapes offer slow-melting properties for cocktails. The COWSAR model is black, matching one of the Antarctic Star’s color options. It also features self-cleaning capabilities. You do not gain significant production speed or capacity. This alternative is for you if you want identical physical specs but prefer the COWSAR brand or specific clear ice marketing. It is a direct functional equivalent for whiskey enthusiasts.

EUHOMY 34-Lb Nugget Ice Maker with Handle

The EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker produces chewable nugget ice, not crescent cubes. It offers a higher daily capacity of 34 lbs compared to the Antarctic Star’s 27 lbs. The unit is narrower at 11.6 inches wide but taller at 13 inches. It includes a carry handle, enhancing portability beyond the standard Antarctic Star design. You sacrifice the clear, slow-melting ice ideal for neat drinks. Instead, you get soft ice that chills rapidly and is suitable for snacking. The steel light silver finish stands out against the black original. This model suits you if you prioritize volume and texture over crystal clarity. It is a practical choice for households that consume ice quickly for mixed beverages or ice-based snacks.

TUATNUT 44 lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

The TUATNUT model significantly increases daily production to 44 lbs of nugget ice. This is much higher than the Antarctic Star’s 27 lbs. It produces chewable nugget ice, differing from the crescent shape. The footprint is unique at 8 inches wide and 12 inches deep, making it narrower than the original. It stands 12 inches tall, which is shorter than the Antarctic Star’s 15.8 inches. You give up the slow-melting crystal ice for high-volume chewable ice. The grey silver color differs from the black original. This option is for you if you need rapid ice for large gatherings or parties. It fits users who value speed and volume over the specific texture required for premium cocktails. It is a high-output alternative for busy environments.

EUHOMY 34 lb Nugget Ice Maker with Handle

This EUHOMY unit produces 34 lbs of nugget ice daily, exceeding the Antarctic Star’s 27 lbs. It makes chewable nugget ice rather than crescent cubes. The dimensions are 11.6 inches wide, 13 inches tall, and 9.45 inches deep. It weighs 19.6 pounds, slightly lighter than the original. It includes a carry handle and self-cleaning function, adding convenience. You lose the clear ice texture that resists dilution in drinks. The black finish matches one of the Antarctic Star’s options. This model suits you if you want portability and higher ice volume for camping or RV use. It is a practical choice for those who prefer soft ice and easy mobility over the specific crystal structure of crescent ice. It balances capacity with transportability.

Frigidaire Gallery Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

The Frigidaire Gallery produces 44 lbs of nugget ice daily, double the Antarctic Star’s output. It makes chewable nugget ice, not crescent cubes. The unit is taller at 16.8 inches and wider at 14.6 inches. It is deeper at 10 inches wide. The navy color contrasts with the black original. It includes self-cleaning features. You sacrifice the slow-melting crystal ice for high-volume chewable ice. This model is for you if you need restaurant-quality ice for large households or frequent entertaining. It offers superior volume but requires more counter space. The taller profile may limit placement options. Choose this if you prioritize daily ice volume and chewable texture over the compact size and crystal clarity of the Antarctic Star. It is a high-capacity alternative for serious ice users.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Antarctic Star Countertop Crescent Ice Maker

Best for: slow-melting ice for cocktails

Daily Ice Production

27 lbs/24h

Ice Type

Crescent

Form Factor

Countertop

Batch Time

15 min

Water Supply

61 oz water tank

Features

Self-Cleaning

View on Amazon: Antarctic Star Countertop Crescent Ice Maker Affiliate link

This countertop ice maker produces 27 lbs of slow-melting crescent ice daily. It generates 16 cubes in 15 minutes using a 61 oz water tank. You get three adjustable ice thickness settings for different drinks. The unit features a self-cleaning cycle and operates with one-touch controls. Its compact design fits easily on most counters.

Pros

• Produces 27 lbs of ice per day
• Generates 16 cubes in 15 minutes
• Offers 3 adjustable ice thickness settings
• Includes a one-touch self-cleaning cycle

Cons

• No smart app or remote control connectivity
• Heavier build at 22.3 pounds
• Lacks a digital display for status monitoring

Good fit if

• You want slow-melting ice for whiskey or cocktails
• You need quick ice production for parties
• You prefer simple one-touch controls

Skip if

• You require nugget or pebble ice
• You need smart home integration
• You want a lighter, portable unit

Verdict: Antarctic Star Crescent Ice Maker delivers clear, slow-melting cubes for drinks that need chilling without dilution. It suits those who value simple operation and consistent daily output over smart features.

2 Also great

SenCre 26.5 lb Countertop Ice Maker

Best for: Quick bullet ice for small gatherings

Daily Ice Production

26.5 lbs

Storage Capacity

1.32 lbs

Ice Type

bullet

Form Factor

countertop, portable

Batch Time

6 minutes

Water Supply

1.5L water tank

View on Amazon: SenCre 26.5 lb Countertop Ice Maker Affiliate link

The SenCre countertop ice maker produces bullet-shaped ice in 6 minutes, with a daily output of 26.5 lbs. It features a 1.5L water tank and 1.32 lbs storage basket. You get two ice sizes and self-cleaning. This silver unit measures 11.9 by 12.1 inches. It suits home or office use. The compact design fits most counters.

Pros

• Produces 9 ice cubes in 6 minutes
• 26.5 lbs daily ice production capacity
• Self-cleaning function for easy maintenance
• Two selectable ice sizes for different needs

Cons

• No refrigeration function to store ice long-term
• 1.32 lbs ice basket is small for large gatherings
• Requires manual refilling of the 1.5L water tank

Good fit if

• You need ice quickly for parties or drinks
• You prefer bullet ice for cocktails or smoothies
• You want a compact unit for a home bar

Skip if

• You need to store large volumes of ice
• You prefer nugget or crescent ice shapes
• You want a unit with built-in refrigeration

Verdict: SenCre Bullet Ice Maker, 26.5 lbs/Day delivers fast ice for small gatherings. It fits users who value quick production and easy cleaning over large storage.

3 Also great

COWSAR 27 lb Crescent Countertop Ice Maker

Best for: Slow-melting clear ice for premium drinks

Daily Ice Production

27 lbs/24h

Ice Type

crescent

Form Factor

countertop

Batch Time

12-15 minutes

Features

Self-Cleaning

Application

Home, Office, Party

View on Amazon: COWSAR 27 lb Crescent Countertop Ice Maker Affiliate link

The COWSAR Crescent Ice Maker produces 27 pounds of clear, slow-melting ice daily. It generates 16 cubes in 12 to 15 minutes. The unit measures 14.1 by 9.45 by 15.8 inches. It features one-touch self-cleaning and a 24-hour timer. You get portable countertop ice suitable for drinks that need dilution control.

Pros

• Produces 27 pounds of ice per 24 hours
• Clear crescent cubes melt slowly for drinks
• Generates 16 cubes in 12 to 15 minutes
• Includes one-touch self-cleaning function
• Portable design fits kitchens, offices, and RVs

Cons

• Lower daily output than nugget alternatives on this list
• No smart connectivity or Wi-Fi controls
• Lacks a remote control for operation

Good fit if

• You want clear ice that keeps drinks cold without watering them down
• You need a simple one-button interface for quick operation
• You require a portable unit for offices or parties

Skip if

• You prefer chewable nugget ice for beverages
• You need more than 27 pounds of ice daily
• You want app control or smart home integration

Verdict: COWSAR Crescent Ice Maker, 27 lbs/24h delivers clear, slow-melting cubes for whiskey or wine enthusiasts. It suits you if you prioritize drink quality and simple, portable countertop operation over high-volume nugget production.

4 Also great

EUHOMY 34-Lb Nugget Ice Maker with Handle

Best for: Chewable ice and portable drink stations

Daily Ice Production

34 lbs

Storage Capacity

1.8 lbs

Ice Type

nugget

Form Factor

countertop, portable

Batch Time

6 minutes

Water Supply

1.2 qt water tank

View on Amazon: EUHOMY 34-Lb Nugget Ice Maker with Handle Affiliate link

The EUHOMy Nugget Ice Maker produces chewable sonic ice in as little as 6 minutes. It delivers up to 34 lbs of ice daily from its 1.2 Qt tank. The unit features a built-in handle for easy transport and self-cleaning for low maintenance. It suits you if you want fast, soft ice for drinks or snacking without waiting for slow melt cubes.

Pros

• Produces 34 lbs of nugget ice per 24 hours
• Makes ice in just 6 minutes per batch
• Includes a carry handle for portability
• Features a one-touch self-cleaning cycle

Cons

• Small 1.8 lb internal ice basket requires frequent emptying
• Uses a manual 1.2 Qt water tank instead of a direct line
• No remote control or smart app connectivity listed

Good fit if

• You prefer chewable nugget ice for sodas or mocktails
• You need ice quickly for daily family use
• You want to move the unit between rooms or offices

Skip if

• You require a direct water line connection
• You need to store large batches of ice for later
• You want a larger 27 lb+ daily production capacity

Verdict: EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker, 34 lbs/Day fits you if you want fast, chewable ice for drinks and snacking. It is a practical choice for mobile use thanks to its handle, though you must refill the tank manually.

5 Best kitchen

TUATNUT 44 lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: High-volume nugget ice production

Daily Ice Production

44 lbs / 24 hrs

Storage Capacity

3 lbs

Ice Type

Nugget

Form Factor

Countertop

Batch Time

5 minutes

Water Supply

3L+1.2L tanks, 0.8 gal side tank

View on Amazon: TUATNUT 44 lb Countertop Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

This TUATNUT countertop ice maker produces 44 pounds of nugget ice every 24 hours. It generates a batch in just 5 minutes. The unit includes a 0.8-gallon removable water tank and a 3-pound internal storage bin. It operates at less than 50 decibels. This machine suits you if you want fast, chewable ice for drinks or smoothies without waiting long for production.

Pros

• Produces 44 lbs of nugget ice daily
• Makes ice in 5 minutes
• Includes a 0.8-gallon removable water tank
• Operates at less than 50 decibels

Cons

• Small 3-pound internal storage capacity
• No automatic water line connection
• Manual cleaning required monthly

Good fit if

• You need high-volume nugget ice for parties
• You prefer chewable ice for smoothies
• You want quiet operation under 50 dB

Skip if

• You require bullet or crescent ice shapes
• You need an automatic water line hookup
• You want a larger storage bin than 3 lbs

Verdict: TUATNUT Nugget Ice Maker 44 lbs/Day delivers rapid, high-volume nugget ice for households that prioritize speed and chewable texture over large storage space.

6 Best budget

EUHOMY 34 lb Nugget Ice Maker with Handle

Best for: Portable nugget ice for small spaces

Daily Ice Production

34 lbs per day

Storage Capacity

1.8 lb

Ice Type

Nugget

Form Factor

Countertop

Batch Time

6 minutes

Water Supply

1.2 Qt water tank

View on Amazon: EUHOMY 34 lb Nugget Ice Maker with Handle Affiliate link

This countertop unit makes chewable nugget ice in six minutes. It produces 34 pounds daily from a 1.2-quart internal tank. The 1.8-pound storage basket holds enough ice for short-term use. It operates quietly under 45 dB and includes a self-cleaning cycle. The compact design fits easily on counters or in RVs. You get portable convenience with a built-in handle for easy movement.

Pros

• Produces nugget ice in 6 minutes
• Generates 34 lbs of ice per day
• Self-cleaning cycle for low maintenance
• Quiet operation under 45 dB

Cons

• Small 1.8 lb ice storage basket
• Requires manual water tank refilling
• No app or remote control features

Good fit if

• You want soft, chewable nugget ice
• You need quiet operation for home use
• You move the unit between locations

Skip if

• You need continuous water line connection
• You require large ice storage capacity
• You want smart home connectivity

Verdict: EUHOMY 34lb Nugget Ice Maker is a quiet, portable option for nugget ice fans. It suits you if you prioritize chewable ice texture and easy mobility over large storage volume.

7 Best premium

Frigidaire Gallery Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

Best for: High-volume nugget ice needs

Daily Ice Production

Up to 44 lbs daily

Storage Capacity

3.97 lbs

Ice Type

Nugget

Form Factor

Countertop

Batch Time

10-15 minutes

Water Supply

Reservoir (no water hookup)

View on Amazon: Frigidaire Gallery Countertop Nugget Ice Maker Affiliate link

This Frigidaire countertop ice maker produces 44 pounds of crunchy, chewable nugget ice daily. It generates its first batch in 10 to 15 minutes. The unit features an auto self-cleaning function and a drawer with a viewing window. You do not need a water hookup, as it uses a built-in reservoir. The matte exterior fits modern kitchens.

Pros

• Produces 44 lbs of ice per day
• First ice ready in 10-15 minutes
• Auto self-cleaning function
• Drawer access with viewing window

Cons

• Uses a manual water reservoir instead of a direct hookup
• Dimensions are 16.8 inches high and 14.6 inches long
• No mention of Bluetooth or smart app connectivity

Good fit if

• You want soft, chewable nugget ice for beverages
• You need high daily production of 44 lbs
• You prefer a hands-free cleaning cycle

Skip if

• You require a direct water line connection
• You need a compact unit under 14 inches wide
• You prefer traditional hard cube or crescent ice

Verdict: Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker 44 lbs delivers restaurant-quality chewable ice quickly. It suits households that prioritize high volume and easy maintenance over smart features.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions